SOTS Defensive Player of the Year Set Not Redeeming

I earned enough tokens to get the Lou Groza and the Ray Guy award kicker and punter.  But when I go to the defensive player of the year set to add them to get the 96 OVR Jacob Rodriguez it gives me the plus sign to add the punter,  but shows the magnifying glass for kicker.  The game seems to think the player is not in My Items when it clearly is