EAFC25 UCL second leg couch coop broken

Hi,

EAFC 25 on PS4’s UCL second leg mechanic is broken. After the first leg, there’s no option to go the second leg from the post-game menu. 

Quit game - scores from first leg aren’t carried over.

Restart game - restarts first leg.

How can something that gave me and my younger brother so much fun over the last few years has been completely ruined now?