Forum Discussion

xPats4Lifex's avatar
xPats4Lifex
Seasoned Ace
2 years ago

In Depth Suggestions for Creation and Presentation

I am truly disappointed with this year's release of Madden. A promised "make or break" game has fallen way short yet again... Other sports games are miles ahead of Madden in all aspects of creation and presentation. Improving on these features would add a level of immersion and authenticity that is so desperately needed to bring life to this game. We have been given the same generic face scans, same recycled presentations. Franchise mode lacks any depth as well as superstar mode. 

For starters, the character creation equipment menu is very messy and unorganized. Equipment should be sorted by brand/color like previous versions of Madden. THE BIGGEST ISSUE with the new "sapien technology" player models are the pants. Players do NOT wear pads over their knees anymore and this should of been fixed with the new player models.

Equipment

  • Being able to pick home/away equipment (colors, gear, etc)
  • Cold weather gear
    • Why was the sleeve temp option taken away? This kills the immersion even more.
    • Add neck scarves, hoods, etc
    • Hand warmer thats built into the jersey (ex Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen)
    • Face coverings (ex Ja'Marr Chase)
  • Being able to put turf tape/sleeve on one arm (ex Desmond Ridder)
  • Being able to wear multiple sleeves on one arm (ex Patrick Mahomes)
  • Being able to wear multiple arm bands on one arm (ex Jamal Adams)
  • Add turtlenecks (ex Justin Fields, Jalen Hurts, Patrick Mahomes)
  • Add neck band gear and Q-collar (ex Jamal Adams, Jevon Holland, Tony Pollard)
  • Add scrunch socks
  • Add mouth guards that attach to helmet/hang off face mask
  • Add more mouth guard/chin strap options
  • Add rolled shooter sleeves
  • Add 3/4 sleeves (ex Brock Purdy)
  • Add knee braces over and underneath the socks (ex Mac Jones)
  • Add shoulder braces
  • Add ankle braces
  • More color options for gloves, cleats, etc.
  • Add padded arm sleeves (ex Justin Jefferson and Stefon Diggs)
  • Add custom thigh pads that players have been wearing with their numbers and team logos (ex Jaylen Waddle)
  • Add colored visors (ex Stefon Diggs)
  • Add a variety of head bands to equip on players
  • Add wrist bracelets

Character Creation

  • THE MOST IMPORTANT... GET RID OF THE GENERIC FACES AND GIVE US A FACE EDITOR LIKE EVERY OTHER SPORTS GAME! HAVING THE SAME RECYCLED FACE SCANS FOR EASILY 5+ YEARS IS RIDICULOUS. Every other EA Sports title/major sports game has a face editor of some sort (Madden only gives you a very minimal face editor for superstar mode that has also been used for years. Many of the generic faces do not match what is on the picture, many of the faces are the exact same, many of them do not fit in helmets properly, and MANY of them are extremely messy looking. (This would be amazing in draft classes but the face editor was taken out of the beta for some reason?)
  • ADD TATTOOS!
    • EA FC added in tattoos that you see on many real-life players and the option to add them to your created player. The same applies to NBA2K which has a very extensive selection for tattoos to add to created players.
  • Add more facial features (eyes, nose, mouth etc)
  • Add more hair/facial hair options
  • Custom run animations, pass animations, celebration animations, pre/post game animations for created players (ex NHL, EA FC, NBA2K, MLB The Show)

Visual/Presentation (MANY of these were in previous version of Madden years ago, and many are features that are in games like EA FC, NHL, NBA2K)

  • Updated pregame animations
    • Players engaging with reporters and fans (signing autographs, interviews, etc
    • Players walking in/out of tunnel
    • Players getting off plane/bus
    • Pregame warm ups (would be cool to be playable like NBA2K)
    • Show players coming out of the locker room, getting ready in the locker room
  • BETTER HALFTIME
    • Show players in locker room
    • League highlights
  • Update postgame animations
    • Again engaging with fans and reporters
    • Players doing jersey swaps
  • Make the weather conditions feel lively
    • Snow is by far the most disappointing. Bring back the heavy snow!
  • UPDATE THE DRAFT IN FRANCHISE
  • MAKE THE PLAYOFFS FEEL DIFFERENT THAN PRESEASON AND REGULAR SEASON GAMES
    • Add NFC/AFC championship celebration and trophy presentation
    • MAKE THE SUPER BOWL worth the grind...
      • We have had the same presentation for years...
      • Have players wearing Super Bowl gear after winning
      • Longer overall celebration
      • A REAL HALFTIME SHOW
      • Have a banner celebration the next season (ex NBA2K)
      • Have players take off their helmets
    • Make stadiums feel authentic
      • BRING BACK CROWD CELEBRATIONS
      • Have fans leave during blowouts, bad records etc
      • Add mascots
      • Bring authenticity to each stadium
        • 12TH man waving flag, Patriots rining bell outside lighthouse and shooting the muskets after a TD, Vikings blowing the horn, etc
      • Bring back the fans that would dress up with face paint etc.
  • AUTHENTIC SIDELINES
    • Another year of having generic and distorted player models on the sidelines...
    • Add assistant coaches and coordinators
    • Add medical tent/staff 
      • Injury animations need a complete refresh
    • Have players take off their helmets
    • Have players wearing hats, cape coats, etc.

I understand that the presentation probably cannot be dramatically changed this year but improving on the character creation could GREATLY improve on the overall experience.

8 Replies

  • Really sad that this stuff has been neglected for so long despite the community begging for more player customization every year. This year was even worse because the basic editor was broken on launch. Madden is far behind the EA eSport games in this area and most other eSport games. Very disappointing. 

  • xPats4Lifex's avatar
    xPats4Lifex
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago
    @dvdbrownr they have this random shorts option that doesn't do anything, the spats are all messed up as far as colors, multiple cleat options don't show up on both feet, many helmets dont fit properly on created players, and so much more. It is more broken this year than it was last year. Many of the generic faces have been recycled since like PS2
  • EquipmentGuy1k's avatar
    EquipmentGuy1k
    Seasoned Traveler
    2 years ago

    Thank you finally someone that understands what I be saying they not adding new equipment that works and how does superstar mode have so much things of equipment and you can your cleats color I don't get it 

  • stahlherzog's avatar
    stahlherzog
    Seasoned Adventurer
    2 years ago

    Well thought out and great post.  Normally I focus more on game play issues and things like play calling AI, custom playbooks, custom plays... but you are spot on and they should be able to do both things.  The worst thing to happen to Madden Football was the NFL exclusive license.  Killed any need for improvement.

    Concur and double Bumped. 

  • xPats4Lifex's avatar
    xPats4Lifex
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago
    @EquipmentGuy1k exactly, doesnt make sense to me either. 2k, The Show, EA FC, NHL all have way way way more depth to creation, creation is equal from their "career" modes and their regular create a player. Madden gives us the bare minimum once again.
  • xPats4Lifex's avatar
    xPats4Lifex
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago
    @stahlherzog i don't understand why they cant do both things... like look at 2k or any of these other games. Madden is miles behind all of them. sad thing is ive made these long posts for years to only see these features get slimmer each year
  • @xPats4Lifex Madden cares too much about ultimate team instead of franchise mode.

    In fact, in the new "MOST FEARED" update they put ultimate team as the first mode instead of your recently played. Insanely predatory behavior from EA to try to get you to pay your money on cards that you can't even bring over to other future maddens.
  • xPats4Lifex's avatar
    xPats4Lifex
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago
    @ee6bi18t93yt what blows my mind is that every other sports game has their own version of ultimate team. 2k, EA FC, The Show etc all get love and depth on their other game modes. Madden is the ONLY sports game that gives 0 attention to the game besides MUT. I think Madden should stick to making Madden mobile and hand over rights to a new company that will give people that don't play MUT a good experience for the first time in a decade.

About Madden NFL 24 General Discussion

Join the community on the forums and talk about your passion for Madden NFL 24.4,271 PostsLatest Activity: 3 hours ago