Do you have players in your lineup who previously had X-Factors enabled? remove them from your lineup and try again to activate the 3rd x-factor.
I keep getting an "Exceeded the maximum of 3 players with x-factors enabled for the offensive lineup" message. I only have 2 players enabled with X factor. When I go to do the 3rd I get that message. So I'm stuck playing with only 2 x-factors which puts me at a disadvantage. I have put money into this team, so I would like to be able to have all 3 X factors. This is only happening on the offensive side of my team.
Had this problem and found THIS reddit post about the same issue but from madden 23. What i did to fix was if you had a previous player with an x factor (for me tua) and instead of taking off the x factor from the upgrade menu you instead refunded it, it would glitch out and your player would still have it enabled in the active superstars. I tried one way but theres to my understanding two ways to fix this. What I did was remove tua from my lineup (i moved him to a backup so i just put in a low ovr qb i had) and activated the superstar which worked. Another way that I haven't tried was to go and rebuy the superstar ability and properly remove it before refunding the ability.
