Error in OT play (Franchise Mode)

In Franchise Mode, the other team scored a touchdown on the first possession. Then I scored a Touchdown on my next possession and the game was 21-22 after I scored the touchdown, without letting me kick my EP to tie th game up, the game was “Final” with me losing. When in reality my extra point should have tied it and the ball should have gone back to the other team for a next score win’s situation