Simulation on Superstar is terrible

When you have a defensive superstar (CB, FS, EDGE, LB), the offense becomes completely inept. No matter what you do you’re watching your offense go three and out constantly or turn the ball over six or seven times a game. I’m watching them go for it on fourth down instead of taking field goals. It stops being fun when the game is consistently working against you. Why is my QB the only one in the league with more interceptions than touchdowns every season? I can’t justify buying this slop again next year