@DunbarDenton ☹️ did the file path for your game change while doing the renewal? on PC, the files should be stored somewhere in the "user"-section (in my case it is "C:\Users\Anwender\Documents\Madden NFL 21\saves"; its German, "Anwender" means "user" but I'm not sure whether it is named the same in the English version). maybe you could search there for the old folder and try to copy it into the new one (if you created a new one due to the renewal).
hope that helps. good luck!