Forum Discussion

cuttingteeth's avatar
cuttingteeth
Seasoned Novice
3 years ago

Momentum Meter in Madden:

I like the intentions of the Momentum Meter, but the end result isn't clicking for me.  I would like it removed or the ability to turn it off, as I feel that it not only affects sliders and ratings, basically nulling them...but it is also unrealistically unfair overall.  It just doesn't fit into a true "simulation" mode like whomever thought was accurate.  If you just have to keep it in the game, I would personally only keep it in the ARCADE mode.  It could feel right for that mode only, as it is reminiscent of NFL Blitz in several ways.

In more detail - gaining momentum on my side, and suddenly the away team can't run routes as well because of the field, etc. - the kinds of advantages that hit per the momentum meter just don't make sense for only one team to suddenly have.  If the field has degraded, that's something that affects both teams.  That's just one example, but I promise you that they are all in that same vein, really.

Again, overall, I like the idea and intentions, but the implementation just doesn't fit into the "simulation" mode.  A lot of people are justifiably thinking that it's what has overpowered the defense and interceptions / fumbles fest going on, as well because when the meter swings far enough, the festival of turnovers begins.

I'm not the average Joe and just here to rant without reason.  I hope you take this as calmly as I have written it.  This is level-headed thinking and no anger or trashing intended.  There is a ton to like about the game.  I saw this area to give suggestions, and this is simply that...a suggestion after hours of experiencing the game and in various modes.  Thank you for your time. 

20 Replies

  • I disagree,  i love the momentum bar , even though it it is annoying when your on the wrong side of it.

    It gives the game a real feel like it was intended for.

    I feel like can be adjusted a little,  like for franchise modes have a way that players can customize different momentums for home games to give true home field advantage in real nfl

  • Pr0fK1tso's avatar
    Pr0fK1tso
    Seasoned Traveler
    2 years ago

    The Momentum meter has been one of the single worst ideas that the madden team.at EA have implemented.

    And you wonder why the folk playing fifa keep speaking about their game being controlled?

    Momentum sucks...big time. It needs to be gone or the casual madden player will be gone.

    I've seen games where teams take 2 or 3 plays and they're top Momentum...yet other teams struggle. That's not what I would call Momentum at all.

  • Pr0fK1tso's avatar
    Pr0fK1tso
    Seasoned Traveler
    2 years ago
    @buckmane225 How's is your screen shaking like a tree in a category 3 storm make it feel real?. My nephew was literally sick first time he saw this in a game.
  • ssmitty91's avatar
    ssmitty91
    2 years ago
    @mynameiscark I agree 100%. I was thinking about this earlier, it makes no sense for super specific yet generic boosts for these stadiums. The same things are affecting different stadiums, so why are there completely different perks. Weather, Crowd Noise, Player Experience. Those are the factors, each should have a few variables that cause different affects.

    Keep. It. Simple. Stupid.
  • @Pr0fK1tso You can turn the screen shaking off. I actually enjoy the momentum meter as it gives the game more of a challenge, but the screen shaking is truly terrible.
  • In head to head the games rarely finish. Once one of us gets the momentum, the other is likely to quit. Why not? You can no longer throw a completion. The QB doesn't even know what play was called.

    As implemented, momentum is absurd and overdone. Let me turn it off or at least control how strong it is.

  • Start the game and they return the kick. Momentum bar fully in their favor before I even touch the ball. No chance at that game… wtf

  • Ctylertheking's avatar
    Ctylertheking
    Seasoned Newcomer
    1 year ago

    100% agree people can say it makes it feel real but the fact is its a game and it takes the gamer skill out of it when its giving the team with momentum a better chance at everything love the game but the momentum is the absolute worst thing about it and its terrible.. i have momentum more often than not and i feel bad for the opponents because if im winning I dont need madden helping me beat them worse and if im losing i dont need em making it harder to come back and make it interesting again