Solved
Second Controller will not activate for Head to Head (Local) Madden 16
Anyone know how to activate your second controller to play head to head when in the "Play Now" screen and choosing your teams??? 3 weeks ago we purchased Madden 15 for our first XBox One system. M...
Okay had the same issue as you did about not seeing a second remote. When I called in this morning they told me it was a known issue and asked if I had any device plugged into the Xbox. (Guitar hero dongle) I told them I did and he said go ahead and remove it and magically I could see he second remote.
Microsoft is now getting a call to hopefully resolve this known issue.
