Forum Discussion

7 Replies

  • Usually when a company has rights to a movie and nothing has happened for this amount of time it's not going to, especially since series popularity dipped after Andromeda.
  • Fred_vdp's avatar
    Fred_vdp
    Hero+
    7 years ago

    I agree. It's been in development hell far too long.

    I would personally prefer a TV series to a movie, though, but I think TV needs to evolve further so that it's feasible to do Mass Effect on a TV budget. In any case, I think it should be a tie-in, not a straight adaptation of the games.

  • An animated series, be it hand drawn or CG would probably be the best bet. Even successful scifi shows get cancelled due to fx budgets being too high.
  • ThandalNLyman's avatar
    ThandalNLyman
    7 years ago

    @AeromusPrime22 wrote:
    ... Even successful scifi shows get cancelled due to fx budgets being too high.

    Maybe, but I think that's rarely the case.  The producers factor in those costs from the start.

    We've had a number of long-running sci-fi TV successes:

    Battlestar Galactica (redux) - 4 seasons, 75 episodes
    Babylon 5 - 5 seasons, 110 episodes
    ST TNG - 7 seasons, 178 episodes
    ST DSN - 7 seasons, 178 episodes
    Westworld (3 seasons, 20 episodes, still in production)

    And look at Dr. Who; a show with excellent writing and a (large) devoted fan base can succeed despite using some pretty cheap (and cheesy) FX!

  • AeromusPrime22's avatar
    AeromusPrime22
    7 years ago
    Well there are different factors, but Farscspe and The Expanse where both killed because SyFy didnt want to pay. You can calculate costs but if shows get popular actors and what not will want more money.

    Star Trek really isnt a good example as its got such a strong fanbase, it csn pretty nuch succeed with anything. B5, well its amazing what Straczynski was able to do with his budget and season 5 happened by the skin of its teeth.
  • ThandalNLyman's avatar
    ThandalNLyman
    7 years ago

    @AeromusPrime22 wrote:
    Well there are different factors, but Farscspe and The Expanse where both killed because SyFy didnt want to pay. You can calculate costs but if shows get popular actors and what not will want more money.

    Star Trek really isnt a good example as its got such a strong fanbase, it csn pretty nuch succeed with anything. B5, well its amazing what Straczynski was able to do with his budget and season 5 happened by the skin of its teeth.


    Well, actors wanting more money has nothing to do with the FX budget.  And having "a strong fan base" is important for any on-going media production.

    I'm just saying that there are lots of reasons sci-fi shows and movies succeed or fail.  For projects that get greenlighted the FX budget isn't likely to make the top five in that list! 

  • AeromusPrime22's avatar
    AeromusPrime22
    7 years ago
    Normally, probably not, but it does happen. Farscspe was one (all the cg, puppets and new aliens added up). But yes, sometimes the company just screws over the show like Firefly, Space Above and Beyond and Crusade.

About Mass Effect Franchise Discussion

The fate of the galaxy lies in your hands. Join the Mass Effect community forums and tell us how you'll fight for it.19,178 PostsLatest Activity: 2 years ago