Goalie control settings not being saved

So in my be a pro, and maybe every mode, when I start a fresh game from launch I have to pause as soon as I get in game. Then goto settings, and then controller settings, and then adjust the "tether" option and the "hug post" options because I dislike the defaults. Then as long as I don't quit to home screen and I keep the game running those settings are saved. However..... if I quit the game and then come back later in the same day, or even a couple minutes later because that last play was ridiculous those two settings have reset back to default and not saved. 

I have specifically played multiple games in a row and saved over my previous save with the settings set how I want them only to come back later and they are defaulted again... this same problem happened with nhl 24 also. So tell me I'm not the only one that would like these settings to save like the rest of the settings haha?