I feel that in NHL 24 the push shove was a bit more effective (I play offline).
With NHL 25 - the push shove still is every effective for the AI but I find there is a nerf or change to how it works (it's useless at all times now).
I think that is where my issue lies. Prime example of this is a win in the offensive zone back to the right or left defense man- it's usually an 80% chance the AI will push shove you off the puck, which can lead to a breakaway or odd man rush but if it's attempted by my user controller player doing the same sort of movement it just slides off of them with no loss to their balance, momentum or loss of puck.
It really can build an imbalance and to a point show that the AI has a controlled advantage over the user.