CPU Goalie

Can anyone explain the goalie behavior in online play to me? Especially in Clubs.

It happens so often that our goalie is absolutely terrible. Specifically, he always (under any circumstances) rushes way out of the crease! Lately, it’s been happening almost every single game. Whether it’s a simple slap shot from the blue line, a breakaway, or any other play, he just wanders far out of the net, giving the opponent an incredibly easy goal into an empty net.

But when my club mates and I do the exact same plays, moves, or shots, the opponent's goalie is always perfectly positioned inside his crease, never steps out, hooks everything, slides smoothly, and tracks the puck flawlessly.

Our goalie is just completely broken. Can anyone explain why this happens? We are losing 9 out of 10 games because of this!