Yeah, drop-ins are a world of difference compared to a club that has played together for years. A team of lesser skilled players individually that have fantastic chemistry are still going to be a challenging team to beat. And I don't see an issue with that. Especially as a goalie, I would think you'd want a solid team that knows how to play together in front of you. It would be a nightmare to be a goalie in a pick up game with all random players. In most cases at least.
What region are you in? What console are you on? We don't always have a goalie so I could see about running some games with you sometime.