Missing MSP Card from Trade Quest

Did you think you would get a free MSP from that set? You got a pack and the traded 91 and 89 overall cards back as stated in the reward description, and you thought you would get a 95 overall MSP on top of that when it costs 5 91 overall cards to build a 94 overall MSP?

Anyway, the answer to your question is that the collection sets don't give us MSPs. They are themed around the MSP players, but they just give us free packs if we happen to have all of the players needed in one or more of those sets. You should take a look at the reward descriptions of those sets and see that they don't say anything about MSPs.

To get the 95 Hamilton through sets you would need to trade in all 5 94 overall MSPs and then you would get all 5 94 overall MSPs back as BND and the 95 Hamilton as UT.