You have to go into the club roster from the club members tab. Then select the person you want to assign captaincy to and hit triangle/Y. Must be the creator or a GM to do this.
Community ManagerHello, @RGCreflex
You can set this in the Club Members screen.
Has been glitching for so many clubs this year. Won't allow us to set alternate captains but we can change the captaincy. Assuming this will never be fixed this year given EA's track record and the fact im seeing posts on reddit about this dating back to at least a month ago...
Community Manager
