Forum Discussion

Jbear1186's avatar
Jbear1186
Seasoned Newcomer
2 months ago

NHL 28 Early Suggestions

These are things based off of what I haven’t seen in the NHL 27 trailer that have been released, some suggestions still have a chance of making the game, just not announced.

1: LIVE FRANCHISE: This is a pretty obvious one, it would be really convenient to have this, especially if you’re playing franchise mode in the middle of the current NHL season. This would include you being able to start from the current day in the NHL with real life stats and records. It would also include moves and signings that have happened in the NHL so it’d be really convenient just to have this aside from GM connected and this could be a toggle use option if you don’t wanna play with real life stats or anything just do your own thing you can do that too similar to what you can do in the NBA 2K games. Hopefully this is added in next year‘s game.

2: WINTER CLASSIC OR STADIUM SERIES MODE: this is another one that is very reasonable to ask for. This would really help going along franchise mode as well as it would provide real life events and just make the franchise feel more real or he just wanted to do a regular play game exhibition game of this mode. It’d be a fun mode to play along your friends or just have the experience of being in an outdoor stadium. It would be a great addition to the franchise and I’d be very excited to see it if it comes up. 

3: ADDED COMMENTATORS: I know it’s the first year of new commentators, there’s a step in the right direction. But since we’re taking it to account for next year’s game, I would really like to see some more commentators than just two this also delve into a different topic with different broadcasts. As you know we’ve seen that NHL has acquired licensing for official goal songs for teams, would it not just be cool to have an ESPN broadcast, TNT broadcast, or just a made up local broadcast similar to real life, but not like Bally sports or Scripps sports or anything. That’ll be too much work.. It would just add more onto the bigger presentation in the NHL 27 is in introducing and to make the game feel more lively and less scripted. 

 

4: SMOOTHER AI: now this is another one that you can’t really judge because the game is not come out yet but even so it’s just an improvement every year and obviously this suggestion will come up. Hockey is meant to be fluent, not sharpie or unrealistic or robotic. That’s the thing these last few years for NHL games. The gameplay just doesn’t feel fluid at all and it’s just pretty annoying to see players dump pucks in every single time when you’re on the breakout. Now yet again I haven’t seen improved AI in NHL 27 yet because it hasn’t come out as I will see if the gameplay AI has improved or not. But like I said, it’s not one of those things that goes on as the years go on and will eventually get better.

 

5: MORE CUSTOMIZATION: this goes for creative team create a goal horn create a player. The customization in this game is just very lackluster. What if we had custom logos, we could upload directly from our phone? What if we had a real life face can like NBA 2K games do that import our faces into the game? It’s a little less talked about topic, but I would like to see more customization options when I’m creating a team. When I’m creating a team, it just feels really unrealistic and not modern to the real NHL. Maybe there could be a suggestion box or AI Helpe uniform uniforms, logos, and team details stay up-to-date to real life NHL and if you don’t want to that’s fine, but if you wanna have something that actually matches the modern NHL style, maybe some AI can help you create something similar just to make you feel you fit in with the league.

That’s it for now.

8 Replies

  • I 100% agree with all of this, and honestly I think EA has a much bigger opportunity here than just adding another couple of modes or polishing the gameplay every year.

    Hockey’s fan base has grown a lot, especially with the exposure from the Olympics, and I really think the NHL series should start looking at how to create a game that has something for every type of hockey fan. Not everybody wants to grind HUT or play competitive online modes. Some people want realism, some want Franchise Mode, some love customization, some care about presentation, and some just want to build their own hockey world and get immersed in it.

    One area I think desperately needs more attention is customization.

    Create-a-Team has been around forever, but it still feels pretty limited compared to what games in other genres allow you to do now. I’d love significantly more uniform templates, striping patterns, fonts, shoulder designs, alternate jersey options, pants, gloves, socks, helmets, logos, arena branding, and so on. Even if EA doesn’t want to allow complete image uploads, the developers could create hundreds of additional generic logos, patterns, graphics, and design elements themselves so that teams don’t all feel like they were created from the same 20 templates.

    Goalies especially could benefit from this.

    Give us way more goalie pad options. Different pad shapes, graphic designs, color zones, blocker designs, gloves, stick tape, equipment styles, and maybe even manufacturer-inspired templates without necessarily needing every real-world brand license.

    EA could create their own standard equipment designs specifically for customization. Give us 30, 40, or 50 different pad graphic templates and let us recolor every section individually.

    And custom goalie masks could be absolutely insane.

    Look at what modern racing games allow people to do with car liveries. Players can place shapes, decals, numbers, logos, gradients, patterns, and hundreds of individual layers. Why couldn’t something similar exist for goalie masks?

    Imagine creating a completely unique mask for your goalie, then making another one for Hockey Fights Cancer night, another one for the playoffs, another for the Winter Classic, and then changing the entire design when your goalie gets traded.

    That kind of feature would create entire communities by itself. People would spend hours designing goalie masks and sharing them online.

    And customization shouldn’t stop at equipment.

    Arena customization in Franchise Mode could become one of the coolest parts of the entire game.

    Let us control the actual atmosphere.

    Let me choose the primary and secondary lighting colors in the arena. Let me determine how aggressive the lighting effects are when the team enters. Let me change the colors of basic ice projections. Let me customize LED ribbon boards, scoreboard graphics, goal lighting, spotlight colors, entrance music, goal songs, goal horns, and crowd effects.

    You could even have different presentation packages.

    Maybe one franchise has a very traditional hockey presentation with white lighting and classic music.

    Another team could have an almost concert-level entrance with moving lights, strobes, lasers, projections, smoke, and synchronized effects.

    Another could have something completely unique based around the identity of the city or team.

    And with how quickly technology is advancing, I think they could eventually take this even further.

    Give us some kind of simplified arena editor.

    Let us place props around the entrance tunnel or arena. Maybe banners, lighting fixtures, inflatable team logos, flames, smoke machines, LED structures, decorative pieces, or objects related to the team’s identity.

    Imagine creating a team based around knights and having giant medieval-style props near the entrance.

    Maybe your team is based around aviation and you have hangar-style scenery around the tunnel.

    Maybe you have a wolf-themed team and the arena goes almost completely dark during introductions with red lighting, fog, and wolf imagery projected onto the ice.

    It doesn’t need to become NHL mixed with a full CAD program. Just give players enough tools that two custom franchises can actually look and feel completely different.

    Specialty nights could tie directly into all of this too.

    The NHL already has games throughout the season that have different themes, awareness campaigns, military appreciation, Hockey Fights Cancer, community nights, heritage celebrations, and other special events.

    Imagine having specialty games in Franchise Mode where teams wear alternate warmups, the boards or ribbon displays change, the lighting changes, the ice projections change, and maybe your goalie uses a special mask.

    Then you could have the Winter Classic and Stadium Series as actual events instead of just another game on the schedule.

    Outdoor stadium. Different presentation. Different crowd atmosphere. Different uniforms. Special entrance sequences. Maybe even changing weather conditions.

    Those are the things that make an 82-game Franchise season feel like an actual season instead of playing essentially the same presentation 82 times.

    And honestly, this is where I’m probably going to say something some people won’t agree with:

    Maybe we don’t need NHL 28.

    Hell, maybe we don’t even need NHL 29 immediately.

    If EA came out and said, “We’re taking additional development time because we want to fundamentally rebuild and expand the NHL experience,” I wouldn’t be mad at all.

    I’d rather have them take the time and create one massive step forward than keep releasing a new game every year where we get a few improvements, a couple presentation changes, some gameplay tweaks, and then start talking about the next one.

    Technology is advancing incredibly quickly. Hardware is stronger. AI tools are getting better. Procedural systems are getting better. Customization tools are getting easier to build. Games are becoming more dynamic.

    Take advantage of that.

    Build an NHL game that doesn’t just look better but actually FEELS different.

    A game where the AI plays believable hockey.

    A game where Franchise Mode feels like you’re actually running an NHL organization.

    A game where the presentation changes throughout the season.

    A game where creative players can spend hours designing teams, goalie equipment, uniforms, arenas, and entrances.

    A game where casual players can jump into an outdoor game with friends.

    A game where hardcore hockey fans can obsess over realism.

    A game where somebody who barely knows hockey can load it up because the atmosphere, customization, and presentation are just fun.

    That’s what I think the NHL series needs.

    Don’t just make NHL 28 because it’s the next number.

    Take the time and make the NHL game that people look back on five or ten years later and say, “THAT was the one that completely changed the franchise.”

    Because if EA actually combined improved AI, Live Franchise, outdoor games, multiple broadcast presentations, deeper customization, specialty games, custom arenas, equipment customization, unique entrances, and a genuinely modern Franchise Mode into one polished game…

    I would play that nonstop.

  • ManixLiquid's avatar
    ManixLiquid
    Seasoned Newcomer
    2 months ago

    Hi. I would like to add some suggestions. Keep in mind I still play NHL 25. Didn't buy  26, 27 because barely any changes in franchise mode so I'm not aware of new things that should be fixed.

    Retirements

    They are players (forwards & defensemen) aged 35/36 rated 90 overall, have a 80 points+ season and retire. Ut make no sense. I barely see any goalies rated over 80 retireing. A simple fix: players aged 34 & over can only retire if they are rated under 80 overall.

    Also, have MORE retired players becoming coaches & scouts. I don't like seeing mostly custom coaches/scouts.

    Trade deadline

    Please decrease UFA players trade value during trade deadline. We shouldn't pay full value for player rental. During the draft, UFAs player have low value though.

    Also, we should be able to browse available players by position. We can only scroll left to right or by team to see who is avaible. But if I'm only looking for a goalie, I shouldn't have to scroll or look each teams trading block one by one. It's also annoying when to scroll left to right to see who is available, a trade happens, the list reset and I'm back at the beginning of the players available on the market.

    Also the ability to "tag/track" players as we enter the trade deadline. Meaning if I'm interested in a player I should be able to track him. If he is about to be traded, I should be able to make a counter offer to try to get him. There's no bidding war currently during trade deadline.

    Trade Market Hub Central

    It would be the same hub as the trade deadline but all year long. During the season/off season, I shouldn't have to look for each individual teams trading blocks or find a trade to see who's on the market. One hub were we can see all players available (and being able to browse by positions) would be a time-saver.

    Edit players

    It's offline franchise. Let us have the ability to edit overall, contracts, x-factors for all players around the league.

    July 1st Free Agent Frenzy

    No players signs between July 1st & 3rd. Why? It would be fun to have a free agents bidding war of July 1st. Have a fast timer between noon and midnight (similar to trade deadline) and we have the ability to make offers to free agents. Also, no more "you didn't offer enough money or another team offer me more money" without the option of out bidding or make a new counter offer. Current game you offer a contract and cross your fingers the USA player signs with you without the ability to make a counter offer.

    Amateur Scouting

    We should be able to scout faster then the current model. I don't want to select each individual prospects to scout. For exemple if I scouts in SHL, I would be able to choose "scout all players in rounds 1-6 for potential for 10 weeks instead of selecting each individual players. It's too time consuming. Auto scouts need fixing because some scouts assignments last way late in the summer August, even September. And only 20 scouts isn't enough for both pro and amateur. I usually turn off fog of war and uses all 20 scouts for amateur.

    Editing strategies

    It is frustrating that each game i want to play I had to edit strategies every time to the style I like to play. I read it's worse in nhl 27 because we can't even edit strategies. I get it to have playbooks but if we can't edit current playbooks we should have a custom playbook "my playbook" we can assign to our team. I want to play a style i want too. For Be a pro, it make sense. You should be able to adjust to the coach or lose time on ice. But on franchise, we want to have control of our team.

    Front loaded contracts and bonuses

    It would be cool to have. It should make a difference when signing UFAs. Having more bonuses and/or a front loaded contracts might convince a UFA to sign with that team.

    Expansion teams

    We shouldn't be limited to 33 teams at the beginning of franchise mode. If I want to expand the league in the 4th year in franchise, I should be able too. If I want to add another 34th team in the 7th year, it should be an option.

    History books

    Please add history books for franchise years we play. Not a complete history of the league 100+ years, just for franchise. We can't look at past players stats, standings, playoffs brackets, drafts, awards. We shouldn't have to take screenshots or write things down to keep track of all the years we play/sim. I can't even look at the past Stanley cup winners after 25 years in the game. It makes franchise mode pointless.

    Players stats/league leaders.

    It would be nice to have teams logos next to all the players name when looking at stats. I wouldn't have to scroll down to each individual players to look at their profile to see teams they play with.

    That's all I have for now 🙂

  • In my opinion, the IIHF uniforms should be improved, and the atmosphere there could be better, too.

  • EA_Aljo's avatar
    EA_Aljo
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    2 months ago

    Appreciate all the feedback. Thanks, everyone!

  • NHL 28 Feature Request: Multi-Category Player Filters

    I’d love to see a better player search/filter system in Franchise Mode for drafting, trading, free agency, and scouting.  Instead of only sorting by one category, let us select multiple filters at once to narrow down players.  For example:Overall 80+ + Age 25 or younger + Skating 85+ + Shooting 80+ + Physical 80+The search would then only show players who meet all of those requirements.This would make it much easier to find specific players and prospects when building a team. Even a simple system with minimum/maximum values for multiple attributes would be a huge quality-of-life improvement. Please consider adding this for NHL 28! Thanks boys

  • EA_Aljo​ we need the Outside arena shots back for the Pre game intro for nhl 28 Then the pre-game intro would be perfect.  

  • Hey guys,

    So, I’ve been playing NHL 27 since release. And I just want to be absolutely clear nothing here is coming from a place of being dissatisfied, it’s just I think there are a few steps that the NHL franchise can take to go from good to great. I’ll try and summarize here as best I can, but I’m more than willing to expand on any of these topics if you’d like. 

    1. Improvements on Graphic Fidelity and Player Likeness: Ideally, each NHL player should get the opportunity for an accurate face scan. This would go leaps and bounds toward immersion so that if I’m playing on a line with Jack Hughes he actually looks and behaves like him. 
    2. Deeper Character Customization: MLB The Show is the best thing I can compare this suggestion to. I want to be able to customize my characters appearance to make him look and feel like he/she is unique and not simply a cookie-cutter preset who’s equipment I can customize. The ability to add scars, marks, tattoos, deformities (such as a crooked nose from a prior break) etc would go leaps and bounds for allowing the end-user to create a truly unique character. 
    3. Optional NHL Companion App: Develop a companion app so I can be connected to the game from my mobile device, for both Be A Pro and Franchise. Each BAP/Franchise save would receive a unique linking code to link to the companion app, where I can view stats etc and compare online with friends or globally. Eventually, being able to make some off-ice decisions (specific examples being trades for franchise and training for BAP) would be honestly sick. Incorporating face-scans of the end-user for BAP character generation would be sick as well. 
    4. Explore the use of Generative AI for select in-arena Voice Lines: The specific example I can think of for this would be for Referees. Immersion would go a long way hearing a Referee call penalties in addition to the current slew of animations. 
    5. Be A Pro and Franchise Career Expansions: This is where I’m going to start to get a little bit critical and long-winded. I hate this energy system in Be A Pro. I’m sorry, it’s just not the wave and seems like a way to use all of your accumulated energy in BAP to get insane amounts of trait/X-Factor points to upgrade my pro. Instead of that, I’d rather go back to the old-school off-ice training system from prior years. On top of that, add an optional “Career Mode” where I can actually do things outside of playing games and navigating menus. This could incorporate a player’s apartment/hotel room, ability to connect with the players family, friends, and teammates, and the ability to use the money I earn through my career for customization and make my BAP career.. mine. Do the same for Franchise mode where I can actually interact with players, coaches, agents, and the media on a deeper level, as well as the ability to customize my GM’s appearance/office and maybe show him sitting in a suite during a game watching it unfold. 
    6. Be A Pro Contract Negotiations: Let my agent actually represent me. Introduce clauses in BAP contract offers and the ability to negotiate terms, salary, clauses, and promises throughout my pro’s career.
    7. NTCs and NMCs for trade negotiations should be interactive, and behave exactly how they do in the real world. Meaning, if I try to trade for a player who has a NTC, I should still be able to add them to the proposal, but they have to approve the trade as they would have to in the real world. Same with outgoing players from my team. I’d also like it to be clearer what teams are on a players trade list in the case of M-NTC’s rather than finding out the hard way when I go to add them to a proposal. 
    8. Give the NHL Universe a memory. If I spend 15 years with a team in BAP and get traded.. make my first game back in that arena mean something. Make an event out of it. Same for retirements. The ability for a club to retire my jersey after spending my entire career with them and potentially ending up in the hall of fame should mean something. 

    Thank you for suffering through my novel. I feel like if work on NHL 28 started today, a decent chunk of these could be done and done quite well. Again, I am not displeased at all, just looking for a few ways to bring the franchise from good to great. I apologize if anything in here is a repeat of previous suggestions, and I hope I’ve done a decent job at giving everyone some insight as to my thoughts as to where to go next. 

    Thanks again, and I’ll see you beauties in the barn.