I didn't try TS3 until TS4 was already out. I got a free copy with Late Night expansion pack which I played for a short time but didn't get into it. Then later I thought I should buy a bundle with Seasons, Pets and Generations. I ended up returning the bundle before two hours had passed (bough it on steam) because I just wasn't feeling it. I wanted to like it for the horses :( I keep thinking that one day I'll try TS3 again but it hasn't happened yet. My main playstyle is rotational, so that's one issue. I imagine it's better for legacy type of play so maybe it will work out for you.