@Nikkei_Simmer it's a question I hope more of us have. I'm a butch lesbian. I've never worn makeup and I get lost with it for sims too.
Legit most of my custom makeup right now is scars and wounds, tears, and a
few matte lipsticks (I think one by Aikea_guinea and another by Elexis). I found Gosik's eye makeup to be way too over the top for me to use and nixed it a while ago. While PralineSims' makeup looks fine,
there was a controversy over her potentially stealing textures from LemonLeaf and no matter how dubious the claims were, I just couldn't get over the bad taste it left in my mouth (also her skins used to be really, really bad IMO).
But I often
want to make a "glamorous" character who ends up looking like they did their styling at Walgreens instead. I can pair eyeliner and lipstick okay but blush? Contour? Nose masks and shine? Jesus Christ it is
wild talking to other simmers about how they style their sims.
Anyways, I'll look through the links provided. Thanks guys.
