Supernatural or Pets?

I bought all EP's as soon as they were released, so the question of choosing never popped up in my mind. If, however, I should have to pick one of them today, I would definitely choose Pets, as the animals are very well made and lifelike and I think EA's versions of werewolves is ridiculous. Concerning the content, Supernatural offers more, together with a world that has many flat lots, easy for those who love building but aren't experts - myself included...
Just to add some confusion in your mind - do you have Seasons? It is the one and only addition I could not do without!