[HSY] Sim without a crush keeps getting crush related moodlets

Something similar is happening to me! I don't have those same settings, but my sim developed a crush. I had her get over the crush, but keep getting wants in regards to crushing on this sim. I check the sim profile and that crush sentiment is gone. The only time I see that crush anywhere is when my sim has a crush on someone else, I click to try getting over a crush, and that other crush is in the panel too...I'll click that sim, it'll say she's over that crush. And then the wants come again. So, basically, my sim is stuck with this crush and can't get rid of it, despite having gotten over it.

I have the same as Kaseyanne in that my Sim has got over the Crush but still gets related moodlets and Wants related to them

As for the OP, I find that the other Sim having a Crush on you gives you the same moodlets too

Can anyone experiencing this issue possibly share a save file where you've seen it occur? Thanks so much!

Instructions for sharing files: http://answers.ea.com/t5/The-Sims-4-Bug-Reports/INFORMATION-How-to-Send-User-Files-to-The-Sims-4-Team/m-p/6065302

You can DM me the link to your files (note that I may not always respond) or you can upload them via this Google Form: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfmGBSvKURn9Ew6FLZDXs3cgAjYUGgkqMWbpvehGHmK4CX_ow/viewform

I have a similar but not exactly the same issue.

In 2 saves with 2 different sims so far, the sim has had a crush and tried to get over it.

The blue popup message comes saying that the sim will "no longer be plagued with thoughts of" the sim they had a crush on.

The Crush sentiment disappears from the profile of the sim they had a crush on.

However, they still get crush-related moodlets and Wants for that sim.

What's different for me is that when they try again to get over that same crush, the same sim still appears in the panel, despite the fact that the sentiment is gone.

Trying multiple times to get over the crush always gives the successful blue popup message and the sentiment remains gone, but the moodlets and Wants never disappear.

In one of these two saves, the sim continued to have crush-related moodlets and Wants long after her crush grew up, died of old age and became a ghost.

Crushes never seem to go away despite my Sims best efforts. Every time a new crush comes up the "Get over Crush" panel still shows all the previous crushes. It says they will no longer plague her, but they will haunt her for life. 

Yeah, I've had a similar problem from time to time. Most recently, in a completely mod free save, I had a sim you got a crush, dated her crush, then had a fight and broke up, so I had her use the "get over crush" function until it said her head was clear and the crush sentiment was gone BUT she constantly got wants to talk to and ask out her "crush", who is now actually her ex who she hates. Like...I get that's kind of funny, and maybe a little true to life, but I feel like the feature is not working as intended lol. 

I will say, after quitting and restarting the game A FEW TIMES, this problem SEEMS to have gone away. 

Still having this issue in another save with another sim. Crush sentiment gone, but sim still pops up in the "Try To Get Over Crush" panel, and crush-related wants appear for that sim.

Where it seems to get stuck, I've noticed, is when the object of the crush becomes a young adult while the crush is active.

Seems like this is an issue if you are crushing on a sim and either you or the other sim ages up to a young adult. The game also treats a crush from the other sim as you having a crush as well. If I get a crush and get over it, I can see on my info panel that the other person still has a crush on me. Then if I get a 2nd crush and go to get over it, the original crush will also show up on the list to get over. It doesn't matter how many times I get over the crush, the option is still there. If I get over all crushes at least once, I no longer can load the menu to get over a crush unless I get a new one. So, it seems some places are only considering crushes my sim has and other places are also counting crushes other sims have on my sim. No mods in this save ever.

As teenagers my Sims "got over their crushes" and still as Young Adults - Elders get Wants regarding their teenage crushes even if they are married and with other Sims. It's almost as if the crush status doesn't clear or something.