I checked my sim's inventory, her husband's inventory, and went home and checked the household inventory and the shed. I do not know if I had the debug cheat activated in my game at the time. The next Finchwick Fair coming up in my game is the Llama one. I can use the debug cheat with that and see if it makes a difference, however it also could only occur with cows and not llamas.
I traveled to town and back home many times, but sadly Godiva never returned. There shall always be a great love in my heart for my precious Godiva, both the chocolate and the cow. May the gnomes watch over her wherever she may be.
