I got a similar but slightly different issue:
I made the high-level offering and received the Surreal Focus moodlet, and that night a couple Order members showed up.
However they never invite me into the Order even though I followed all the steps. I can't interact with the Order members either, they just stand outside my house for a few hours and then leave without anything happening.
(For reference, packs installed: Every EP except C&D and GTW, every GP except Vampires and Strange, plus the Laundry & Movie SP's)
