If you had to pick a totally new EP, GP, or SP, which one would it be?

Magic.

Activities, but not only related to sports. All kind of hobbies.

Anything athletic. There just isn’t enough athletic opportunities in the game. I’d like more athletic careers, more athletic aspirations, more competitive gameplay, maybe a festival for athletes like the city living ones.

If activities are hobbies basically like freetime I'd love that...

All of those except the playable careers.

I really miss the cleaning skill. At the moment whenever my sims scrub the floor they gain acting skill points instead. And cleaning objects yields nothing at all, it's somehow dissatisfying. But even so I'd love more chores.

Superheroes & Villains
So I could legitimately fulfill Nancy Landgraab's secret Power Girl cosplaying dream.
Also CoX bank missions, that alone would be worth an EP.

Nothing interesting there, Wished more teen related stuff and maybe werewolf

Hmm I feel nearly all these options could be bundled into one domestic style pack. All very similar in what they add to the game: home life (tbh shoulda been in base game some of these features, hope you’re taking notes sims 5), I do think there are some good ideas but realistically, the maids struggle to clean your house as is, let alone adding more chores for them to do. The maid would become redundant as she’d never be able to clean your house in time. The maid wouldn’t be the only thing affected, just an example. I find even when I have neat sims, the house soon piles up and they only make dirty plates as is lol... Would be good if it could be implemented without botching other things. But I guess that goes for every pack they release ?

There's multiple ideas but some could work better as free updates

Wedding SP

Fairies GP

Witches GP

Robots GP

Hobbies & Activities GP / EP

Parents to be plus Babies GP

Teen Stuff SP

Elder Stuff SP

Werewolves GP

Fairytale Stuff SP

I literally want all of that. :D I just thought the other day how I'd love to see house painting in the game. But I also want sports and other activities like biking.