Re: I can't complete Agnes' "Not so useless?" errand

I did a little experimenting and finally got Agnes to accept my pumpkin. Here's what I found of your possibilities:

1. I had only one errand with her, which was the "Not so useless?" errand. No go on needing to do another errand first

2. The batch she accepted was orange and small as well. I didn't use fertilizer on them, but I also didn't use fertilizer on the batch before, which she didn't accept.

3. It was my third try pumpkins, not 6th

4. All my pumpkin tries happened during summer

5. I didn't can with any of my failed batches

All of that said, I think it is most likely that you need orange pumpkins to fulfill this errand. Fertilizer, canning, seasons, amount of tries, and other factors mentioned don't seem to be relevant. Cheers!