"crocobaura;c-18255715" wrote:
I don't think we need sims to hold very meaningful conversations with one another. I mean they should be able to display those conversation icons in a way that makes sense, based on their interests, hobbies, likes, or wherever is going on in their lives, but I don't think it needs to go deeper that that. It would be nice though if they managed to make sims behave in a meaningful way, like if they dislike dancing then they shouldn't start dancing on their own because there is music on the lot.
I agree with you. I don't think anyone really wants smarter AI for characters like The Sims, not really. I will post a few examples. Smarter 'Sims' would mean players have very little control over their characters. And since I have played this series for more than twenty years, I have seen the complaints in all the iterations when AI was smarter.
Example one: When a Sim runs out of the house in TS4 to go speak to a total stranger. Whether that is smarter AI or not players were annoyed (me) when this happened often. The Sim knows why it does that, the player doesn't in TS4.
In TS2, when Sims ran out of the house to go speak to another walkby (lonely) players were annoyed the Sim would break commands to do it, because their social was low, Smarter AI (yeah) but maybe the player wanted the Sim to be very lonely to bring on the Social Bunny.
Good example of a smarter AI, Sim uses the coffee and moves the commands around and drinks coffee first before the other seven commands queued up for the Sim. I only saw this happen once in twenty years and only with a specially coded Sim in TS2. I was amazed that the Sim was smarter than me, and moved the commands around but never saw it again.
Example two: Gossip. Smarter AI would tell other Sims their Sim cheated on partner. Players complain in all the games their Sims can't do a lot of things the player wants them to get away with (in all the series) without another Sim finding out and spilling the beans and or the Sim in the other room being smart enough to know what is happening in the other room. I doubt players will want smarter AI about conversations and gossip systems. And or smarter Sims at all.
Example three: I sincerely doubt we really want smarter AI because smarter AI would have fewer Sims without the same interests and or wants, fears, needs etc. on any community lot if the game is going to decide Jack and Jane are at work, sorry, you can't call them to go to lunch since they don't get a lunch hour today. This was a complaint when TS4 was first released, (2014) players were upset the Sims at work couldn't be invited over, and or seen on a community lot since they were at work. It was one of the earlier patches to allow it.
In TS3 players were upset because Sims were at work or school, too. But griped a lot about just the opposite in TS2. Carl shows up in work clothes at a community lot at 9:00 A.M. when we knew he was at work. But we just called him at home and the game said he was working.
Example Three: Players didn't like the 'special hobby lots' were practically empty in TS2. Supposedly filled with Sims with the same interests and hobby interests. Which only lead to a handful or less showing up. It was boring to be honest to go to hobby lots.
Example Four: Players won't like Sims not being able to flip on a dime and like one Sim over the other. Smarter AI would mean Mary isn't going to like Sally and or Paul and or Jerome or anybody if they don't have the same interests and or needs and or wants or interests. I've watched for twenty years now how players want to control all that, but if smarter AI thinks it knows better then none of that will be possible, either. And the player will be complaining they have no control. lol
I can list fifty dozen other examples of how smarter AI will not be liked by those who don't like surprises in their games, want to control every detail and or stop Sims from doing things that annoy them (there are ten thousand threads in 20 years about that) and outside of their control. They are going to want ten dozen toggles. ROFLOL