So, my favorite occult normally is the Sims witches. 2, 3, and even 1 if you count Makin' Magic. However, spell casters in 4 do not live up to my legacy of favoritism.
That being said, I think 4 has the best vampires in the Sims series and I adore them. I'd actually have difficulty choosing between my old witches and them.
All things considered, 3 wins out, though, for breadth and variety of supernatural content. 4's is thus far a pittance considering how few we have and how little some are fleshed out (ex. Aliens). Even if I like things like 4's mermaids, you cannot dispute how much more there was for them in 3 (an entire underwater world) that even normal Sims could take advantage of. 2 had a good line up and I liked the ways you would get turn, but it was kind of a pain in the butt to do it.
