I have to be honest about 3D designs

simbass7 wrote:

I think He like the game, he like 3d and he like complaining

that part is definitely true

Sahl908 wrote:

MacJiggles wrote:
but I challenge everyone who thinks they have or have seen REAL quality 3d Springfield art to upload it here and I challenge JoshSherer to find one that he could honestly say is, at least, not bad... or not "Ugly" :wink:

Challenge accepted :D.
This is the best 3D town I have ever seen, by Sk3ly
http://i1354.photobucket.com/albums/q699/sk3ly/e0e367252a86e9794d2c3c4b7fc4153c_zpsbdaafeed.jpg

I'll admit that that particular town happens to implement 3D in a less-than-ugly way and is actually pretty good. However, he screwed it up at the part with the observatory and the magnifying glass. Those hills are the stereotypical ugly hills. He used the grey well. Green and 3D don't mix.

BillionDuck wrote:

JoshSherer wrote:
They're all ugly looking and they never actually look like what you intended them to be. Often times they're so off that you need to tell us what it is. But even if we're able to figure it out, it's still ugly. Sorry for the brutal honesty. It just doesn't work. Ever.

kinda how I feel about most of your threads.

I can understand the concept behind calling my threads ugly, but how do they not "look like what I intended them to be"? They're fairly straightforward and leave little room for interpretation. They're exactly as I intended them to be.

waams wrote:
Here's mine:

http://i.imgur.com/eOJZWIf.jpg

Using the benches as steps looks good. The rest of it looks ugly as sin. Sorry. I hate the green hedges around buildings to serve as a hill. And what's worse is that the building is ALREADY on a hill. So it's not even necessary. But of course you have every right to keep it and be proud of it and the work you put into it. I just find it to be vomit-inducing. But when I jab forks into my eyeballs it starts to look better. Sorry if I sound harsh.

I like very few of the 3D designs I've seen. That being said I find the majority of designs posted get treated like your own child made them. "It's beautiful little guy, you're gonna be a great artist some day".

JoshSherer wrote:

waams wrote:
Here's mine:

http://i.imgur.com/eOJZWIf.jpg

Using the benches as steps looks good. The rest of it looks ugly as sin. Sorry. I hate the green hedges around buildings to serve as a hill. And what's worse is that the building is ALREADY on a hill. So it's not even necessary. But of course you have every right to keep it and be proud of it and the work you put into it. I just find it to be vomit-inducing. But when I jab forks into my eyeballs it starts to look better. Sorry if I sound harsh.

Haha, it's already on a hill!!!

HomerSwapMeet wrote:

hasanmohamma wrote:
Is this turning into a fight for opinon :shock: or a 3D THREAD :lol:

You just gave me an idea buddy :)

Since its starting to look like a 3D thread...

http://files.myopera.com/PolacoJNM/albums/12235602/A%20Clockwork%20Orange.gif

:lol:

These are from a neighbor.

http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8384/8541765850_72ebe26214_c.jpg
http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5460/9320584126_2dc52bd5f9_c.jpg
http://farm3.staticflickr.com/2817/9183758434_597c710cb6_z.jpg
http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5528/9091492698_976c924e8e_z.jpg
http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5534/9072130439_9103a7e290_z.jpg
http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8261/8808649152_0dc534bf09_z.jpg
http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5452/8753602850_f860313592_c.jpg
http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8090/8582704433_0efc49d35e_c.jpg
http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8390/8548044036_f0e983f3f0_c.jpg
http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8096/8553882062_0eb73bc65e_z.jpg
http://farm3.staticflickr.com/2828/9255423901_260f9cd661_o.jpg

All ugly, with the exception of the coliseum and the first building in the first image. Those are decent, though the first one is ruined due to that annoying back fence at the very top surrounding the antenna. Why does that stupid back fence have to be there?

snugglesNY wrote:

JoshSherer wrote:
They're all ugly looking and they never actually look like what you intended them to be. Often times they're so off that you need to tell us what it is. But even if we're able to figure it out, it's still ugly. Sorry for the brutal honesty. It just doesn't work. Ever.

Oh my gosh, I have never more whole heatedly agreed with someone more on this forum. And I think most of the people who fawn over them are the same people small subset of folks who constantly brag about their hideous signatures. Their taste level is generally low.

Truth bombs were dropped by my fellow New Yorker. I agree that their taste level is low. Where in NY are you?

swdonnelly84 wrote:
I like very few of the 3D designs I've seen. That being said I find the majority of designs posted get treated like your own child made them. "It's beautiful little guy, you're gonna be a great artist some day".

So true. Too much coddling here.

HomerSwapMeet wrote:

JoshSherer wrote:
All ugly, with the exception of the coliseum and the first building in the first image. Those are decent, though the first one is ruined due to that annoying back fence at the very top surrounding the antenna. Why does that stupid back fence have to be there?

Dude!

What are you saying? Your not suppose to like this crap!
I'm appalled for your forgiving nature. Don't let me down JoSho! :)

http://tgchan.org/kusaba/questarch/src/127996933061.gif#oh%20hell%20no%20gif

It's okay...my thinking something is okay looking always comes with a catch or a critique at the end. It's not true liking. It's just better than the other crap.