Inconsistent Adesanya star rating

Right now there are 4 alter egos of Israel Adesanya in the MW division. 
The one with the best overall stats is the newly released 243 version, which currently has an overall 4.5 stars.

But the Active version, which has significantly lower stats, has an overall 5 stars. Even is you compare it to the 305 version, that has slightly better stats than the Active version, it also has only 4.5 stars. 
This doesn’t make any sense to me. Ideally you should have the 243 version rated 5 stars, because that’s prime Izzy with the highest stats, and the 305 and active version rated at both 4.5 stars. 
Hope EA makes this change, because right now they way they have rated Adesanya’s alter egos and active version are extremely inconsistent and inaccurate.