Blog Post
68 Comments
- robomelon3148 days agoSeasoned Novice
I'm sure I'm shouting into the void. But I need to make sure I post this outside private servers.
CG have officially released the most soul-less cash grab of a raid ever.
I want to give them props, the raid design is actually good. The enemies look great, the background is better than I thought it'd look from remembering the movie.
Intro cutscenes are sick, they look like there's way more effort than the rest of the raids (since sith raid at least, that one still holds up imo).
However. From an economy perspective, this is apocalypse-level bad for the playerbase.
Zero teams work without a full 5 units to score any real amount of points. There's a full 5 separate clauses that call out teams with less than 5 starting members, and exist solely to punish you for DARING to try to get some value out of the raid.
And that's just at the gear 12 tier.
There's people who have done analysis way deeper than my personal math experiments, but essentially the raid just has exponentially worse return on investment than order 66 (or any other raids).
When the R9 tier was added to the raid, CG was gracious and added a tier, instead of downshifting everything. The R8 tier stayed at 2.7m and the R9 tier went to 3.6m
This time the R8 tier was moved to 1.8m, the R9 tier to 2.7m, and the R10 tier is 3.6m.
A R10 is almost (but not quite) twice as expensive as going from R1 to R9.
To obtain max crate rewards on O66, you could do it with as few as 8 R9 units. Tarkin + 4 clones, and 3 jedi vanguard (mace + 2 others). You could obtain a max personal score of 18m with a further 5 units. GL Hondo and regular Hondo, plus a trio of either more pirates, or kelleran beq and the other 2 members of mace's team.
To obtain max crate rewards on this new raid, you need 15 R10's, and to max personal rewards, you need 25. (Not even counting the requirements for GL mando, since I didn't count the R9's for hondo).
So you're looking at double the units, and double the cost per unit.
It's literally 25% as fast to even pay back what you spent. To get the equivalent in return, Droid Destruction would need to run for literally 6 years, to equal what O66 did in the roughly 1.5 years that it ran.
================
Let's get to the final two pieces, because they're intertwined.
#1 - CG's forum post releasing the raid spelled out squads they intend us to use. This is... "To allow flexibility across character choices"
#2 - Every squad CG wants us to use involves a character fresh off the printers, who isn't farmable f2p.GL New Republic Squad: The Mandalorian and Grogu
New Republic 2nd Squad: Adelphi
Sith Squad: Darth Jar Jar, Ronin
Rebels Squad: Luke Starkiller
Bounties and Mercs Squad: B1 Merc, Jaxxon
ISB and Empire Squad: Stormtrooper Concept
Every. Single. One.
Compared to O66, where we had 3 full teams farmable by that point. Beq JV, Bad Batch, and Tarkin/Clones. Mace's team was just waiting on his event return. Both pirate teams weren't farmable yet. So half the raid had un-usable teams, but we could split the existing to get 4 teams worth.
=========
That's a lot of words to essentially say, CG has both paywalled the raid, AND ruined any semblance of a beneficial reason for players to build for it. It's finally gotten to where I believe they wanted it all along. A treadmill you have to stay on to progress, where they get to speed it up whenever they want. And the only way to keep up is to spend money, or get on the peasants' treadmill that isn't going quite as fast.
=========
So I'm getting off the treadmill. I'm not investing a single relic material into the character list for any raid related reason. If they get upgraded, it's because I want to.
And if there's no changes made. I'm quitting. I refuse to contribute to the KPI's any longer.
CG_Meathead I appreciate almost everything you've done. The only thing I'm not appreciative of, is the fae answer of "undermans are allowed." When the actual answer that the community wanted was "no, sorry. We're preventing any sort of that as much as possible."
I'm sure you had the best intention behind it, but you've ended up treating us like dirt.
If you want some constructive feedback on how I think a raid economy could have been balanced to encourage players at all levels to invest, here's what I'd do:
#1. Hero bonus for Rotta solo. Make him able to solo the raid if he's at R9 or R10. This gives every player a cheap way to get into the raid, and gives a discount on the final numbers.
#2. Give GL Mando a 3-man with two of his marquee team members. Even if it's R10 only.
#3. Give guilds a reason to push for max score together. I'm talking in the realm of 850,000,000 points (to let someone miss and not punish the guild completely). Put era currency, or high end relic mats, or just increase the mk3 substantially (kinda like you did for the personal track).
#4. If you want to encourage building full squads, and reward it in a way that isn't in-game currency, use the innovation you showed by giving team-based hero bonuses to REALLY push the power of the team to the next level. Give us full teams that can beat the raid on auto. Make us struggle to find a strategy for non-prescribed teams, but reward people for doing the raid as intended by giving them less time comittment.
And lastly, R10 is still way more expensive than the rest, it's in no way equivalent to where R9 was in relation to R8 when it was a year out from release. And a lot of that is because the R8 materials and R9 materials needed interfere with existing R8's and R9's that need done. Why would you R10 someone when you could do 3 R8's instead. We need some way to keep up with infinitely scaling relic costs, and keeping the same raid rewards as we had 2 years ago is not the way to do it.
=======
Anyways, I'll be chilling free to play in my guild for a bit longer, since I like the friends I've made. But CG isn't seeing another cent from me unless this entire situation gets rectified with haste. - spideyrulz8 days agoNew Spectator
So we start RotE and are halfway through it and you take away our MKIII rewards! WTH cg!!!
- DRex85_55mpbia58 days agoNew Spectator
Maybe I, and my entire guild have missed it, by why didn't we get an in game date for the shift to the new raid?
Now we ended up starting a raid to get rewards and keep the progress going and you just altered the rewards mid raid, so we miss out on the MK3 rewards 24 hours before finishing the raid. That just sucks... 🤥
- DRex85_55mpbia58 days agoNew Spectator
We're in the same situation.
- y2f9w9xt3bjk8 days agoNew Spectator
This raid is **bleep** horrible. Got to load god mods just to take a turn. Overtuned to hell and back.
- RehydratedFruit8 days agoSeasoned Observer
That's a whole lot of brown! The film colours were so depressing, and now an entire raid which looks like a septic tank for over a year!? Why wasn't the raid with the Dragonsnake! It would have been so much cooler...
- corsagnino8 days agoSeasoned Rookie
Maybe I missed something but can you please confirm if we will be getting our mk3 payout, if we started the raid two days prior to the new raid launch. Thank you
- corsagnino8 days agoSeasoned Rookie
I’m hoping we missed some fine print or message about this
- Criss_Rood8 days agoSeasoned Rookie
My guild is in the same situation!
- cudhreth8 days agoSeasoned Traveler
There is only one correct answer in that survey.