Forum Discussion

Re: AHK/DS4 and EAC

This is just mania. Every single mouse software has features to do basically the same stuff you could do with AHK, and keyboard software. Are you gonna block all drivers?

Not even 0.000000001% of cheaters caught could possibly be using AHK for that purpose. It is so inefficient to use for that kind of purpose.

It really is an outrage, this. You're not even punishing the cheaters at this point...

And to be even more honest. The decision is very uneducated. You haven't looked at the software, and you obviously don't have anyone at respawn using this software

If you did they would tell you AHK is too inefficient and too buggy to be used for building cheats.

Python and Javascript is both easier to learn, have more resources for use and lessons. Or C, C#, C++, hell even Java.

But you don't ban entire frameworks except for AHK? I can have Minecraft open and still open Apex.

If you really do believe it is such an incredible amount of cheaters, or even more than 1/1000: just fetch the current script(s) in memory and scan those for cheating types of scripts instead. See how many out of 1000 people are malicious. It won't even be one.

This decision will lower the amount of cheaters by literally none. It just makes people like me very inconvenient. It really isn't an effective block for catching cheaters.

This is a mistake. Whether you know it or not. You have to think this kind of stuff over thouroughly before messing with peoples productivity in this manner. You're ruining it for thousands and thousands of non-cheaters just to catch one?

The best course of action is to remove the block and fetch the script. Once you find an issue you add a search for it in EAC launch. Then just keep doing that.

12 Replies

  • Midnight9746's avatar
    Midnight9746
    Hero+
    8 months ago

    @zuperkamelen That's understandable, I would be frustrated too if a game had started blocking a harmless program that I use.

    Meanwhile, I've heard a lot of the same things being said for reWASD and other similar programs, (things like how it shouldn't be blocked), however this was a decision made by Respawn in an attempt to combat cheating.

    Edited: I would like to also mention that I have never used any of these programs, (such as AHK, DS4, and reWASD), so I don't fully know what they do outside allowing a PlayStation controller to work as an Xbox controller, or to change what buttons do what, (such as switching the A/B and X/Y buttons). All I know is that Respawn has chosen to block these programs.

  • zuperkamelen's avatar
    zuperkamelen
    8 months ago

    I highly doubt that. What would they do? Press Mouse 1 five times on a press. I mean. It doesn't really give you any advantage. Not really.

    It's also so unreliable.

    What cheats would they honestly do in Apex?

    Starcraft, and the like, I would maybe be able to believe. But why not use C to code the cheat if you're gonna cheat?

  • BallisticMVP's avatar
    BallisticMVP
    8 months ago

    @zuperkamelenNo sir thoose scripts don’t just press mouse1 five times, they can do a lot more. I don’t wanna get into deep detail here, but ahk is a wide spread software used to cheat in a lot of games.

    i lean out of the window now and trust that you really need it for work and it sucks for you, but a program like this cannot be allowed every program that can be used for any kind of automation needs to get removed 

  • zuperkamelen's avatar
    zuperkamelen
    8 months ago

    Then my issue become that you can run a python script for automation, or a C written program, an exe, or possibly even through a .bat file. I mean. Just banning everything running ending with '.ahk.' is ridicolous. It's all about what the script is, and they could collect the script itself to scan it for malicious intent.

    I still would like to know how much one would potentially succeed to automatable, because with the knowledge I have I am still sceptical that you can do anything complicated reliably. In my experience it is not reliable at all with tasks more complicated than just typing out '/u/'. Even this fails sometimes if you do it quick enough.

  • EA_Mako's avatar
    EA_Mako
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    8 months ago

    Hey @zuperkamelen,

    Sorry this has had a negative effect for you.

    Though others have discussed some potential issues already, this would not be the place to expand on how AHK (or any other software for that matter) could be used to automate behavior.

    While it's great that you don't run in the circles that may use similar programs for less-than-legitimate purposes, those circles do unfortunately exist. There certainly isn't a one-stop solution to cheating, but we're constantly adapting and approaching the issue from multiple angles. Feel free to check this out for a bit more information, if you haven't already seen the article.

    Thanks for the discussion and feedback, all!

  • @EA_Mako

    Why block software when people aren't using it to cheat? This is just laziness on the developers. There are plenty of actual cheat menus that exist and work to this day without detection that people are actually using to cheat. Blocking things like DS4 that allow players to customize their layout of their controller and allow them to have higher sensitivity than allowed with in game settings (simply by multiplying input levels) is doing NOTHING to stop cheaters. This is just horrible practice
  • SolitaryMassacr's avatar
    SolitaryMassacr
    8 months ago

    I decided to play Apex after awhile of not playing it due to all the cheating going on.

    Noticed that I can no longer use DS4 Windows. Discovered in other posts this was to prevent cheating.

    I have no idea how this software can be used for cheating. It simply emulates an XBOX 360 controller and allows for custom keybinding and sensitivity curves.

    I cannot stand how slow the controller inputs are in any of the FPS games I play, so I use DS4 windows to amplify them.

    Without this, I can't even turn around to shoot someone behind me in apex before they absolutely melt me, it is physically impossible for me to turn around fast enough since my settings are already maxed out and I have the joystick fully pushed in that direction.

    Mouse and keyboard players have "legit" software from their mouse and keyboard companies that allow for all sorts of things - macros (literal key recordings that allow for more than human input), scripts - allows players to have pre-recorded inputs to remove recoil from guns, basically infinite sensitivity adjustments. 

    The statement made by Respawn on X is completely false: "blocks programs that give players an unfair competitive advantage". DS4 Windows is a program that gives controller players a FAIR advantage.

    There are other ways to detect and ban cheaters, blocking software is not one of them.

    I think a solution moving forward would be to allow DS4 Windows to run, or enable the same customization levels in game that DS4 also provides. This game is unplayable with the current settings. ALC was a great step. Now lets take it further

  • EA_Mako's avatar
    EA_Mako
    Icon for Community Manager rankCommunity Manager
    8 months ago

    @SolitaryMassacre 

    Simply put, because certain people are using it for that purpose. While other avenues may also exist, this isn't an either/or situation where taking action in one area means nothing is being done in other areas.

    This issue is one we're continuing to work to address from multiple angles. Do feel free to check through the above link for our latest update on the matter and thanks for the continued feedback, all.

  • WatchMeShine's avatar
    WatchMeShine
    New Rookie
    7 months ago

    Ds4 windows is the only app that allows you to use the 300$ Dualsense Edge controller on PC with EA games. Blocking access to this app was dumb af, and I have been telling them for 2 months now. It also stops disabled people from using special controls to be able to play video games because of their disabilites.

    EA/Respawn are disgusting to have done this.

  • WatchMeShine's avatar
    WatchMeShine
    New Rookie
    7 months ago
    @EA_Mako
    Then give us support for our controllers. I paid premium for a dualsense edge because I have nerve damage and need the back buttons. Can't use it in none of your games on PC without a "3rd party app". All of your answers on the forums are useless because you provide no solution to people with disabilities that can't use their controllers now.
  • E9ine_AC's avatar
    E9ine_AC
    Hero+
    7 months ago
    @WatchMeShine Sorry to hear about your issues, I know all disabilities can differ from one another. I do have friends though who use blow tubes to play the game due to having no hands or arms 1 of them has them but unable to use them.

    The issue really boils down to people used them for bad things. Despite the good they bring to people bad folks ruin good things. AHK, among all the others in the hackers word typically is going to be doing things it should not though. Most programmers don't run ahk files on startup let alone after start up unless working on a specific thing. When we do have stuff we have to run things like that for we use our working machine and not our gaming machine. Stuff like that for any game can flag systems therefore most use different computers one with their scripts for work and one they game with.

    I assume though if someone is truly running ahk and stuff like it 90% of the time its up to no good. That's just me though but other games and companies also agree they are used for bad far more than the good.

    Im sure there may be something out there that can fill that gap that would be allowed. Foot pedals, Blow tubes, among thousands of other options.

About Apex Legends Feedback

Give feedback about the Legends, maps, weapons, loot and more in the Apex Legends community forums.33,248 PostsLatest Activity: 3 hours ago