I'm having the same exact issue. I even returned my disc for a new copy. It's not the disc and it's not my console..I've tried it on two seperate consoles. There are many other people with this same issue. EA needs to look into this as it is causing many people to not be able to play. I've been a big EA Sports fan for years but with this game and FIFA 14 I've been very disappointed with EA. Things need to be changed.
