I finished an All American and got a pack with 4 players. Not complaining though all were 72+ including a 77 SS which was good to shore up that weak pass defense! What ratings were the Freshman packs? If they are giving out 70+ rated players I might do that instead. All American was not easy, you have to win an extra game to get that pack.
Just finished my all American run, got two field goal packs, 4 players each. Two silver, one 78, the others were low 70's. Won the same number of games as the others.
For some reason I only received one pack for finishing All American. Same with Varsity. I only got two packs when I did the Freshman challenge.
Just rechecked the replay (I saved the video because I beat UCLA and wanted to rub it in to some of my friends who went there) I had to play the National Championship game twice in All American. I was 5-1 in regular season, the loss was due to the server going down and it automatically counts as a loss. They had me play 4 playoff games. So I had to win 9 games for a single pack, of cards but because I played the 9th game I got some extra coins. I think I made 17,000+ doing that. Maybe that loss causes you to lose a pack?
