Play Art Issue - Please Help

I cannot figure out a fix for this. Whenever I call a play on either offense or defense, as soon as I break the huddle, my play art is automatically showing on the field. I then have to press the right trigger to remove the play art, basically the opposite of how it should work. I have this issue in dynasty and play now. Please help, it's such a headache!

Also, it is not a controller issue, I have tested multiple controllers, and this does not happen in Madden or CFB 25.