Lucanis romance bug after Act 1 decision

This still didnt answer as to why people are being permalocked out of his romance. 

You said the quest isn’t bugged but still didn’t answer why people are locked out of his Hero status or romance. if one of his quests it isn’t being marked as complete and Treviso was saved, why are people still being locked out. 

Plus if saving Minrathous also locks you out of his romance and not Neve’s how is that fair? Now if it worked both ways I could understand but it doesn’t. Plus I’ve heard you can’t even get the best ending if you don’t choose Minrathous. Which potentially locks everyone out completely if you want to romance Lucanis. 

It’s either Save Treviso and the game doesn’t bug and you might get the Lucanis romance to work but you’re locked out of the best ending. OR you save Minrathous but are completely locked out of Lucanis’ romance of it isn’t already bugged but not Neve’s.

That’s my thread you’re referencing and even there a clear answer is not given. 

This… hardly answers the question. Please let players know if this is an intentional consequence to the act 1 choice and if it was meant to be a temporary lock until trust is regained, or a permanent lock no matter if trust is regained or not. This is very frustrating and confusing and this more or less lack of an answer doesn’t help clear things up

Hi! Thank you for your reply, however I'm not seeing more info on this particular problem, only that Lucanis' introduction quest is not bugged and not supposed to show up in the quest journal.

We were wanting to know if the player is locked out of Lucanis' romance path if they chose to help Minrathous at the end of A Warden's Best Friend quest? And if so, is it an intended consequence or a bug? Thanks!

I'm sorry, but I'm missing any additional details from the link you provided. It seems like it's the exact same people asking the exact same question and getting the same non-answer.

I don't understand why BioWare just won't come out and say whether Rook has any chance of romancing Lucanis after saving Minrathous. Seems like a very easy question to answer, and the lack of understanding seems to be upsetting more players than it intrigues.

People aren't even asking for an explanation like with Jack and the whole ME2 romance weirdness. Just an answer. Can we or can't we?

Since there won't be any DLCs, it's not like you're going to spoil the next story that will drop in... 2034? We'll all be too told to care by then 😁

It's a great game, but honestly the romances are so awful it would have been a better game without them, and that is more true for Lucanis than the others, sadly. People just want to know if they're wasting time trying. Given how weird it can be to romance Iron Bull (the ONLY option for gay men in Inquistion besides Tim Curry, er ... Dorian), I think it's a legitimate question.