Forum Discussion
- P4st3l1ak2 years agoSeasoned Ace
@Cpayne32that's the spirit! 😎
- mariohomoh2 years agoHero (Retired)@P4st3l1ak Plenty of differences between AC and ACC. Besides what Toto mentioned:
a) AC was built on Kuno's own engine, while ACC was made with UE4. They're producing ACC2 now and it will be on another custom engine, but not because they dislike UE; just because now they think they can customize a custom engine and pack it full of goodies and dedicated tools the right way
b) More robust FFB. They calculate (and refresh) acting forces differently
c) Better physics. The tyre model of ACC is waaaay more complex
d) dynamic weather whereas AC only has static?
If you decide to give iRacing a go, let me know and I'll tip you out. Just the tip though as @TotosHeadphones seems committed with the rest of the bits.
Toto I upgraded to a proper DD set with LC pedals, I mentioned this already but don't remember if you were in the discussion? Anyway, Logitech G Pro wheel and pedals due to availability, console support and - believe it or not - price.
I'm on mobile right now but will share a bit of telemetry comparing my inputs for you ✌🏼
Which is definitely not to nudge you into buying a LC pedal set. Haha don't go about spending money when you're in a low spot in the hobby, specially with other games just around the corner like BG3 and Armored Core!
But a mod? That's something up your alley considering your liking for fiddling with electronics like Batman and iron man. I would never for the life in me consider braking with anything lighter than the G923 stock pedals anymore - though for all intents and purposes its brake pedal is a bit superior to that of stock G29?
Anyway, I just can't go back. One of my first iRacing races where I got a good launch out of the rolling start, I had to double check I wasn't pressing on the clutch pedal instead on my G923 for how light it felt coming into T1. When adrenaline took in, I completely lost the feeling for pedal travel and floored that brakes like they're butter
With LC I'm obviously still subject to scenarios like this, but it is easier and quicker to regain my bearings with force than it is to recover that "ok this much force equals 75% pedal travel which is what I need to not lock up here on les combes" - TotosHeadphones2 years agoSeasoned Ace
@P4st3l1ak, @mariohomoh sums up all the important bits with a merlot and a lovely dessert, I gave you a flat diet coke and rice pudding 😂
Yeah, you did mention that you upgraded. I think I was very jealous. I won't be in the position to upgrade for at least another 18 years, apparently kids are a financial responsibility until then 😭
The G923 uses a progressive spring and I think comes with the rubber block that comes makes it feel like load cell. It's a cheap system that works only until you want to really brake. There are a few load cell mods floating around or a proper kit, haven't decided which one I'll go for. Depends on funds as per usual!
Another problem I'm finding is the wheel inputs; I've always been softly softly with F1, minimal corrections always tracking, so with ACC yo're required to be aggressive and to be on the limit. I can't find that limit without losing time. The feedback is great but maybe I just don't know what to do with it weirdly. The lack of FFB in F1 games is actually detrimental, and switching between the two may be the underlining issue; I plateau on F1, get annoyed, go to ACC, feel like I'm struggling, return to F1, cycle yada yada yada.
Thanks for the offer for telemetry, I'd appreciate seeing it 👍 - mariohomoh2 years agoHero (Retired)
@TotosHeadphones sorry, just converted my iRacing telemetry files for MoTec but had to deal with a work issue here 🙃
This week I raced at Zandvoort like I said, and it just so happens that I had a good race there around May when I still had the G923. So that's the perfect comparison for our purposes here! In a few hours I'll post again with a side by side comparison of my best laps for each race.
For now, this is what I sent @dancrodrigues on Instagram a few weeks ago:
Red trace is braking with the G923. White is braking with the LC pedal. These particular corners obviously benefit from trail braking, with the first one being a heavy braking, slow short corner and the second being a longer corner.
My attempts at trail braking were pathetic before 😂
You can see me trying to progressively ease off the pedal, I could never nail it.
Now these two are for those Zandvoort laps I mentioned. The first is for T1, and the other is for... Jeez, I can't remember the number but it's another corner that requires proper trail braking. Red trace now is with the Logitech Pro Pedals and Blue trace is for the G923:
The coloured background if for ABS activation, same color scheme. Both laps were with the Toyota GR86 that is equipped with ABS. For T1 it's basically "heck screw it" due to the profile of the corner, but most of the times you want to keep ABS from engaging as it reeeeeeeeally bogs you down. TC on this car is the worst, by the way! Really sounds like you're drowning yourself with a pint of beer gugugugugugulp 😂
For LC mods, I recently came across these:
I think there was another one in my subscription feed but I passed on that one, sorry 🙃
Will try to find it again as it was from a good channel.
- mariohomoh2 years agoHero (Retired)
@TotosHeadphones Blatantly double posting just so that I don't forget to comment on your reading of the steering inputs.
An appetizer:
- @mariohomoh Interesting this G29 LC mod, eh? Gonna look for it!
- Cpayne322 years agoHero+@P4st3l1ak WHY DID I AGREE!!!!!
- TotosHeadphones2 years agoSeasoned Ace
@mariohomohThat sir is amazing. Thank you. It's clear that the G29 pedals are far more difficult to trailbrake in a consistent fashion. The second graph for Zandvoort, that LC slope is the exact type that you want to see in proper brake control. G29 is virtually binary on/off.
- mariohomoh2 years agoHero (Retired)@TotosHeadphones The zoom level can throw the scale off and box the traces up. I'll try to do a better job later today
Are you familiar with Motec or McLaren Atlas? Telemetry softwares. - ScarDuck142 years agoLegend@TotosHeadphones Love clotted cream rice pudding 😁
I feel ya. Once upon time I had money then out popped a 7Ib 13oz industrial money burner 😔 - mariohomoh2 years agoHero (Retired)@ScarDuck14 You have a puppy?! 🥹
- TotosHeadphones2 years agoSeasoned Ace
@mariohomohSorry, that was absolutely perfect, my original reply accidentally sent and then I didn't edit my reply. Original reply is edited.
- ScarDuck142 years agoLegend@mariohomoh Close I do call her poopy as she farts and poops like a man 😂
- TotosHeadphones2 years agoSeasoned Ace@mariohomoh I've heard of Motec, I see it alot on a few YouTube content creators videos. I think Gillon uses it? Look forward to a few more traces to cement my plan on getting a load cell pedal
- TotosHeadphones2 years agoSeasoned Ace@ScarDuck14 You and I have very simple tatses 😉
Ahhhhhh, by some miracle I have a fourth money pit on the way. And trust me it was by some miracle 😭 I was out of the fog...and definitely will never see money again - ScarDuck142 years agoLegend@TotosHeadphones Ahh man that’s awesome. I mean one’s enough for me. But I can’t lie whenever I see a baby I get brood.
Congratulations 😂 - mariohomoh2 years agoHero (Retired)
Buckle up, @TotosHeadphones and don't you dare ghost on this community at the end of the summer break now that you got me cooking and stitching these silly screenshots on paint.net, ok? Do we have ourselves a deal? If you disband from this flock again, I'll make it my life's mission to track your family down and introduce all of your offspring to this incredibly cheap and not-at-all time-consuming hobby of Magic The Gathering.
You've been warned 🫶
Here's the telemetry comparison for my recorded laps at Zandvoort. It's an outdated model of the track, prior to the F1 revamp and reprofile it got – but the rescan is already baking on iRacing's oven and will be released sometime this year already.
You can have this track guide to base yourself and get a general feel for the track. Please note that there are chapters in the video, don't go about wasting your time watching it from nil!
The side-by-side comparison of the most important braking events. Red is for my weekend's lap with the DD wheel and LC pedals, and Blue is for my Logitech G923 lap from May. The laptimes were respectively 1:55.590 and 1:56.614 so -1.024s. You'll notice how hard it is to modulate the brake pressure on these potentiometer pedals. I'm not a good driver by any means and there are a bazillion Logitech G29/G923 users that will still smoke me out of the water with their base kit, but it's all about one's journey, isn't it?
As a quick recap, potentiometers don't give a damn for how hard you press the pedal, just for how much you make it move. Load cells on the other hand will measure how hard you're pressing them, regardless of how much movement you act on the pedal.
The mind and body connection is way more fluid and intuitive when you base it on force. When not looking at my foot, I'll be way more consistent applying say 40kgf to a break pedal instead of making it move around 2cm. That's the gist of it.
The forum will most likely miniaturize the image, so right click on it and open on a new tab. Or download it from the attached files.
I asked you about MoTec because if you had it I'd just share my telemetry files with you so that you could analyze them as you please. The rendering above is from a free service, Garage61, that I strongly recommend. The link will probably lead you nowhere unless you have an account on their website, but I'm pretty sure my telemetry is public so anyone can access them. It's iRacing exclusive, but there are alternatives for ACC. Pinging @Monzstar83 as well as I know he digs a little data.
For my routine, it helps immensely that iRacing is quite generous with their data and we've got third-party services like this one, where I can get the average qualifying lap, fastest lap, and race pace/average race lap for the many performance brackets there are.
By performance brackets I mean iRating. iRacing has two trackers for every individual driver:
- Safety Rating – SR: A rolling average of your number of incidents by corner. An off-track equals 1 incident point or 1x, a loss of control is a 2x, a light contact with another car is a 0x but if it is strong enough to disrupt your or their driving it mounts to a 4x, etc. Get that number divided by the a set number of corners and another weighing factor and you get one's SR. The SR will inform the many license classes there are (Rookie, D, C, B, A, and Pro), which will gatekeep you from driving certain cars, cups, or events.
- iRating - IR: It's an ELO based performance system much like chess... or League of Legends 🤷. It's the utmost matchmaking parameter as all drivers registered to a given event are divided in splits according to their IR. So if 56 drivers register to race at Zandvoort in the GR86 cup at 9h15pm, there will be 3 splits of 19+19+18 drivers bunched up by IR, with the top split being populated by the top drivers and so on. Those splits are basically race sessions that take place simultaneously.
In the website above as you can see, we can select a cup, a week (every Monday iRacing opens a new week, with a pre-assigned track for every category), and then find those lap times based on the IR.
You can easily google bell curves for IR distribution across the whole player base, but generally speaking an IR of 2k is considered the big divider. Max Verstappen has a ridiculous preposterous IR of 9347 on his main account plus an IR of 8308 on his fater Jos' account – yeah, Max uses both haha
Just to give you an idea:
That's utterly ridiculous and just goes to show how much of a generational alien Max is. He dominates motorsport everywhere he goes. Don't tell Nico I said that 🫢
Anyway, I use that service to get a few benchmarks, and note them down on this pretty app, Notion. It's a multiplataform note taking and collab tool. Mine looks like this:
Below that I have a track map with corner numbers and names, as well as a track guide with my personal notes for:
G#: gear number at the apex
BM: Braking marker, my reference to establish my braking point. Oh how I wish these would always coincide with the distance boards at the side of the track 😂
BP: Braking pressure and technique
CE: Notes on corner entry
CX: Notes on corner exit
I've converted two of my track notes to illustrate. Here (Brands Hatch with the GR86) and here (Jerez with the Porsche 911 GT3 Cup). It's on Google Drive. Looks time consuming and it was at first, but Notion is sleek and I've got a template that will quickly generate all the relevant fields 🦾
It usually takes anywhere between 5-8h for me to get competitive on a new track and car combo. I could obviously set for less and jump in after 2-3h with no racing line and such, but my ego would snap at me if I'm no good to at least fight for a top 5 finish haha
Those personal notes pay dividends though. When getting back to a track I've already competed in, in 15 minutes of track time I'm back up to speed and can rapidly test my personal best again.
Races are basically hourly, 24/7. But it's tough to squeeze that preparation in on a busy week, so I don't always find the time to compete.
My favorite classes for far are the GR86 cup, the GT4/LMP3 multiclass, and the Porsche Cup with the Porsche 911 GT3 Cup car – similar to the GT3 R but with no electronic aids 💞. There are many, many series with all sorts of cars, including open-wheelers, but driving standards for the lower IR splits are horrendous so I keep a wide berth from them – even though the FF1600, the Dallara F3 and the F4 cars are all delightful to drive.
- ScarDuck142 years agoLegend@mariohomoh you are a super geek
- Monzstar832 years agoSeasoned Ace
@ScarDuck14 wrote:
@mariohomohyou are a super geek@ScarDuck14 honestly @mariohomoh technical posts are a thing of beauty 😍
@TotosHeadphones many congratulations. Following from what Mario said, I made the switch from pots to LC pedals a while back - honestly they are game changing. The consistency you can achieve is incredible under braking.
I did do a bit of research on LG LC mods for my then g923, and there wasn’t much out there but having a quick look now I see MVH (based in UK) have a LC mod (https://mvhstudios.co.uk/products/mvh-load-cell-for-logitech). I highly recommend that company, I bought their wheel rims and they were good quality and customer service was fantastic. I know they put a lot of effort into testing their products and don’t ship junk like others out there.
3DRap also a good company, bought some mods off them. IIRC they’re based out of Italy.
- mariohomoh2 years agoHero (Retired)@Monzstar83 how long have you been on the LC gang? And did you set up a rig or still manages to use those brakes on the floor?
Oh I can already see Toto opening up his bank app and checking on that CC statement 😂
One of us! One of us! - ScarDuck142 years agoLegend
One of my favourite races ever.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xtBiLCa8vcs&t=602s - Monzstar832 years agoSeasoned Ace
@mariohomoh been using LC since early 21. I have a Playseat challenge, and I originally used thick zip ties to secure the pedals, and this worked great. Since then I’ve got the LDS mod to angle the pedals: https://www.lowdownshifter.com/pedalbaseanglesystem.html. It works well, but am finding a bit of roll flex when braking as I’m using my “rig” on a thick carpet.
I’m currently designing a wooden frame the whole rig will be attached to so 1) I can raise the pedal platform even higher so I can achieve formula style seating 2) main seat parts will be anchored to the wooden frame for extra rigidity to help minimise the pedal roll flex on my carpet 3) wooden frame will be modular or foldable still so I can put it away if needed
- Cpayne322 years agoHero+@ScarDuck14 Yeah i agree. Super chaotic
- TotosHeadphones2 years agoSeasoned Ace@ScarDuck14 @Monzstar83 Ahaha More like many commiserations! Thanks though, wasn't in the plan but nothing ever goes to plan...
Right, @mariohomoh please, could have picked Warhammer or something like that or even D&D 😂 None the less, thanks for the in depth post. I don't even know how to reply! I can easily ascertain that LC pedals are the way forward. Thanks for the telemetry breakdowns, I could use it on the PS5 but ACC doesn't send out data which is a shame.
Interestingly, when I felt like I have achieved decent laps I would use the PS5 record function and edit the video of lines and braking points in short snippets to remind myself when I came back to tracks.
As great as iRacing sounds, I don't have the time to dedicate to a schedule. It's got to be whenever I find time these days. Would love the mix of different cars to drive.
@Monzstar83 Thanks for the recommendation. I had been looking at that specific one for purchase or doing the mod myself. Leaning towards buying it but I also want a Bluetooth controller for my phone to do some remote play as the wife and kids got the television 😭 So may go down the mod route depending on PCB lead time etc, but thanks. Thanks for all the advice gentlemen. Gone off the rails slightly but Zandvoort chat will return it all to normal service... - ScarDuck142 years agoLegend@TotosHeadphones Not at all. This is my thread and we can talk about anything you really desire ( Been watching Lucifer ). Although the CMs may have a issue if you get carried away😂😇