Forum Discussion

CO88LER5's avatar
CO88LER5
Seasoned Ace
2 years ago

Up the Us

Up the Us

Promoted to the football league in 1950, Colchester United have spent all but two seasons in the bottom two divisions, bouncing between the third and fourth tiers on a regular basis.

However, calamity struck in season 1989-90, when they were relegated to the Conference, where they stayed for two seasons before roaring back with a Conference and FA Trophy double, under ex-player Roy McDonough.  Fifteen years of subsequent see-sawing between the bottom two tiers ended with jubilation for Us fans, as they finished second in League 1 to local rivals Southend United at the end of the 2005-6 season, to join their Essex rivals in the Championship for the first and only time.  Manager Phil Parkinson thus assumed legendary status with fans but then ruined it by leaving the club for ‘bigger club’ fellow Championship side Hull City before a ball had even been kicked.  Later that season, the fans would get their revenge for what they saw as betrayal, after Parkinson was sacked by Hull City, following defeat to the Us in the league.

The first season in the Championship, under Parkinson’s replacement, Geraint Williams, saw the Us attain their highest-ever season finish of 10th in the second tier.  They spent a number of weeks towards the end of the season flirting with the promotion play-off places, only to miss out late on.  The key to their success that season was the cramped, decaying Layer Road stadium, which ‘bigger clubs’ simply did not like visiting, and a number of scalps were claimed that season.

Some years before, to stave off financial ruin, the club had sold the ground to the council for housing, and now the council were building a new, 10,000 seater stadium next to the A12 trunk road to London, with the intention of filling it every match in the Championship.  It was even constructed with the ability to fill in the corners, raising the capacity to 15,000 (although this has never happened), as fans, club and council got over-excited at the prospect of sustaining the club’s new-found tier two status. 

However, before they got the chance to star in the new council-owned ground, they suffered ‘second season’ syndrome, and finished bottom of the Championship in 2007-2008.

A few years of respectable finishes in League 1 came to an end when the owner reduced his own personal funding to the first team, in the wake of new FFP rules, and, having one of the smallest attendance records in the football league, financial gravity saw the Us drop to the bottom tier.

The last three seasons have seen a constant battle against relegation from the football league, and fan resentment at the owner they claim has overseen this decline.  Until recently, the owner had favoured ‘promotions from within’, from the backroom, for a succession of managers who simply did not make their mark on the team.  However, with the appointment of brothers Danny and Nicky Cowley as the management team, there are hopes that a new beginning may happen.

Cowleys to the Rescue

The Essex-born Cowleys have had success elsewhere, most notably as managers of what were at the time Conference side Lincoln City, who they not only eventually led to League 1 but also famously beat then-Premier League side Burnley in the 5th round of the FA Cup as a non-league side, en route to a quarter-final defeat to the mighty Arsenal at the Emirates.

Further roles at Huddersfield and Portsmouth led finally to this new job back in Essex, where they had previously managed non-league sides Concord Rangers and Braintree Town before their Lincoln stint.  The fans are hoping that the Cowleys’ far more professional approach to team management will reap dividends, take the club away from the bottom of the division and maybe even some distance back up the pyramid.

The Cowleys will need to work with a tight budget, as the owner continues to focus his spending mainly on infrastructure – coaches, etc. – and the promotion of talent from the academy.  The squad does have a number of promising youngsters, notably Samson Tovide, Noah Chilvers and  Bradley Ihionvien, hoping to follow in the footsteps of the academy’s currently best-known product, the Championship’s current top scorer Sammie Szmodics.

We pick up the story in July, with the Cowleys appointing a number of first team coaches and hiring new youth scouts.

175 Replies

  • CO88LER5's avatar
    CO88LER5
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago

    @JustinCase0110
    I get what you are saying, but then this isn't real life; it's just a game.

    The real life Colchester United is in a total mess; they have just avoided relegation from the football league by the skin of their teeth for three consecutive seasons. A real life, or even close to real life, simulation in this game would see them continue to do that, which is not really the point of it all, in my view. Perhaps the real life Danny Cowley (he actually is their manager) might get them to mid-table, or even battling for promotion, but that's all he's going to do because that's their real position in the hierarchy.

    If we all just kept it utterly 'realistic' (as opposed to bending things a bit, and maybe trying to come up with a story that might justify it, as I did with both these players at the time), then this career of mine is effectively finished, because Colchester United in this career have now got as far as they have ever done in real life - and they only stayed in tier 2 for two seasons at that. Not only that, they have never won a 'professional' trophy and yet here I am, with 2 BSM Trophies and an FA Cup. Of course it is fantasy; that's the whole point of the game's existence.

    In the same vein, you have now taken Stockport as far as they should go, to be honest. Anything above the Championship is unrealistic for a club like that. If and when you get them into the Premier League, we will all suspend belief and congratulate you for doing it, because we recognise that it is just a fantasy.

    The thing is, we all bend reality in this game; that's what makes it the interesting thing it is...🙂

    I hope you're not offended by anything I've said, because that is not my intention.

  • JustinCase0110's avatar
    JustinCase0110
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago

    No offence taken mate. Quite the contrary, I was afraid my feedback the other way could have been 'too honest' and caused a raised eyebrow 😉

    I know it's only a game. I just like to keep some parts of a story/journey realistic. And to me smaller steps help to do that, rather than signing too good players too quickly. I signed Mbappé on a free once, to AC Milan. Got pretty boring soon after 😄

    I think I like to play Career Mode, because it is a game mode that is tied to reality somehow. You can take a club from a real life situation/mess and do something good with it. But the point goes missing in my view, if the following steps are not within a grasp of realism. That's just about it. I shouldn't expect others to feel the same way about it. But I like to give feedback to others here, and I suppose a bit of honesty comes with that.

    Anyway, as I said, it's all good man (Saul Goodman). Let's get back on topic... 

  • LABoog4's avatar
    LABoog4
    New Ace
    2 years ago

    Good talk. I think the same. I like to keep it realistic to a point but also enjoy mixing in things to bend reality and make the CM more fun for us. I admit in my Brighton career, I have had too many transfers in the first season. Normally I limit myself to only a few to keep it realistic but I wanted to speed up the rebuild and have fun with it so I went beyond the normal limits. 

    Anyway, back to the CM. Good transfer business, the squad is looking good for the competition and should be up to the task with Europe as well to at least compete in the group.

  • CO88LER5's avatar
    CO88LER5
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago

    Update.

    I haven't been able to keep up with this for a while, and it will be sporadic for the next few months on any forum.

    However, where this career is now is as follows:

    1) Colchester United gained promotion to the Premier League, as runners-up.  They repeated their FA Cup win of the previous season with a battling 2-1 win against Manchester City in the final (just like Wigan shocked them, a few years ago).  This placed them back in the Europa League for their inagural premier league season.

    2) Their "Championship" Europa League campaign was epic, in which they reached the final after the pathway was cleared by the 'big names' such as Barcelona, Manchester United and Manchester City being on the opposite side of the draw and effectively culling their numbers, with Barcelona emerging from the wreckage.  In the end, they were thrashed 4-1 by Barcelona in the final, albeit that it was 1-1 until around the 70th minute.

    So, the club is now in the premier league and currently (after Christmas) sitting a distant second to Liverpool (13 points behind), with Chelsea, Manchester City and Spurs only a couple of points behind them.  They got to the semi of the Carabao Cup and were thrashed 4-1 at home to City, but managed a 1-0 win at the Etihad.  They have just progressed from the round of 32 in the Europa League and have met the manager's target of the round of 16 in the FA Cup.

    On the player side, the club continues to develp and promote kids from the academy, having not purchased any big names with their "promotion money", or indeed the big fees got for Ruiz and Labrovic in the previous season.  The only purchases of any note have been to meet the board's targets (strangely, I had to buy two players from North America) and kids from other teams.   We have managed to keep hold of the most promising players, like the strikers Louis and Aguilar, because we are now in the premier league, and are also in Europe.  They continue to find the net on a regular basis and have got better and better as the season has progressed.  This season, we have loaned out quite a few of the kids and I am looking forward to seeing what I get back, in terms of how they have developed, at the end of this season.

    So, it's going well at the moment, but getting a 'top 4' finish is finely in the balance (the target is 'avoid relegation')..

    I've just downloaded the 25 Beta, so I'll probably play that for a bit now.

  • JustinCase0110's avatar
    JustinCase0110
    Seasoned Ace
    2 years ago

    @CO88LER5 wrote:

    I've just downloaded the 25 Beta, so I'll probably play that for a bit now.


    Welcome back mate. Though it seems the FC25 Beta has made it a short return. I can't help getting a bit envious of you guys getting this early sneak peak to the new game. I suppose I'll just have to remain patient for another 6-7 weeks.

    Colchester United continuing an immense rise with consecutive FA Cup wins, a 2nd place in the Europa League and for now a 2nd place in the first EPL season. Even with European football as a distraction.

    Impressive. Good luck with the beta. I look forward to joining the FC25 community at release.

Featured Places

Node avatar for FC 24 Game Modes

FC 24 Game Modes

Discuss Career Mode, Clubs, and VOLTA in FC 24.Latest Activity: 3 hours ago
1,436 Posts