Forum Discussion

Cupidonel's avatar
Cupidonel
Seasoned Novice
4 months ago

EA FC 25 is definitely the worst game in history

I didn’t want to buy this game — I knew it was going to be a disaster. But like any fan of the series, curiosity got the better of me, so I bought it. Still, I couldn’t bring myself to play more than a few matches. The campaign mode is a complete disaster, and it honestly feels like it was designed that way on purpose, just to push everyone toward online play.

There’s no way to defend properly, and everything seems geared toward one goal: forcing us into the online mode. On top of that, there's the whole politically correct angle — where(probabily) they’re trying to make it so that even people with disabilities — like missing limbs — can score goals in the most popular football game on the planet!

The gameplay is a mess — passing doesn’t work, attacking AI is completely broken, and manual defending isn’t just ineffective, it’s actively punished. Add in the endless bounce backs, and the experience quickly becomes unbearable.
The menus? Well, if the gameplay is bad, at least the menus should make up for it, right? Wrong. The menus barely function. Constant freezing, display glitches, and an absurd increase in the number of clicks just to view your picks — all of it adds up to a terrible user experience.

Co-op is broken too. Let’s say you somehow overlook all the above issues and just want to enjoy some time with your friend in what used to be the best mode in FUT. Guess what? You’d better hope you’re not the away team — otherwise, you’ll get hit with an instant forfeit within five seconds of kickoff.

And it’s not about skill — I actually wish it was just that. Back in 2009, I was actually one of the top players in the series on Xbox. But nowadays, year after year, the defensive system keeps getting butchered in favor of the offensive side — as if, in the minds of these developers, football is only exciting when attacking, not defending. Then again, maybe it makes sense… after all, goalkeepers never win the Ballon d’Or.

I’m a longtime fan of the series. My first “FIFA” was back in 1997, and it was FIFA 96. Since then, I’ve played nearly every title in the franchise. And I’ll be honest — while the series has had its highs and lows, and some entries were even considered terrible, in all my years as a FIFA fan, I have never uninstalled a FIFA/FC game this quickly.

Usually, even with the weaker titles, I’d stick with them for a while — sometimes months. But this one? I picked it up, played 10–15 matches, and uninstalled it with deep regret.

16 Replies

  • EAFC 25 was built on a 2016 engine. What do you expect?  and eafc 26 will use same engine. Frostbite was created for FIFA 2016,

    If they used a upto date engine the game would be soo much better. Its the 1 major mistake their making that's made the game drop over the years as a 2016 engine is not ground breaking on any level, Independent companies have much better engines to work with and the reason indie companies have improved while billion pound companies still use 2016 engines on games released in 2015 and 2026. 

  • brebike's avatar
    brebike
    Seasoned Hotshot
    3 months ago

    Frostbite blows more than an average h00ker on a Friday night. Can't believe it's almost 10 years. I remember i was curious about the new game engine back then, but also very disappointed after playing it.  Couldn't possibly imagine back then how much worse it would even get. And it's still not working! Almost a decade since the last decent football game coming out of the EA studios

  • MrMusic7's avatar
    MrMusic7
    New Adventurer
    3 months ago

    Agree with everything you say, I’ve played it since FIFA 96 too and I have bought every version since but I bought it this year in the hope it improved upon last years which was poor but it was better than 25 which is absolutely broken and unplayable. I have uninstalled it this year for the first time and thrown out my copy of the game disc. I’ll never buy another because I’ve been telling EA for months and instead of making it better they have proceeded to make it way worse!

    im finished with EAFC for good!

    trying to find an alternative game for the future.

  • Wilzzz4's avatar
    Wilzzz4
    Seasoned Novice
    3 months ago

    To be honest that used to be me. But if anyone buys the game again after this year, they can't blame EA, they can just blame themselves. 

    "Fool Me Once, Shame on You; Fool Me Twice, Shame on Me"

  • JGsorholt's avatar
    JGsorholt
    New Adventurer
    3 months ago

    Ea has gone from being a company that developed the best and most quality and fun games to producing garbage.

    Very sad and disappointing development! 

    Hope someone else can take over the development of sports games now.  Because EA has unfortunately lost it. Money has completely taken over quality for Ea sports, and I hope and believe that this will be their slow death to sell sports games.

  • brebike's avatar
    brebike
    Seasoned Hotshot
    3 months ago

    I partly agree. Yes, EA chooses profit over quality these days. The current state of the game is far below what we expect ( it basically s6cks).

    I genuinly think that all this is caused by the lack of a real competitor. Back in the days you also had PES, This is football, etc, the rivalry resulted in some really good games.

     EA has the knowledge and experience to do a lot better, but why would they if they are the top predator on the market? They don't care enough about their customers to make a priority out of making a great game. People will buy it anyway.

    A lot of people are in anticipation of the new UFL game, including me. But I'm also worried. The release of UFL has been postponed since 2022, over and over again. I'm concerned whether they will be able to release new versions each year. I am worried that, if a one hit wonder will knock EA out of the market (which they really deserve at this moment), we will end up without football games in a few years

About FC 25 General Discussion

Discuss the latest news and game information around EA SPORTS FC™ 25 in the community forums.7,684 PostsLatest Activity: 15 days ago