Comprehensive Gameplay & Career Mode Feedback for EA FC 27
Dear EA FC Team,
Here is my feedback and suggestions for improvements that I would like to see included in EAFC 27:
1- Header Variety and Effectiveness: In single-player mode, we want to see a greater variety of headers and headed goals. Right now, headers feel repetitive; we always see the same types of shots and build-up positions. Some headers go wide or high, others go straight at the keeper but lack any real power, and we never get spectacular, jaw-dropping goals. Players feel largely ineffective when trying to score with headers.
2- Lack of Playstyle and Attack Variety: Attack actions always come down to the same patterns through the center—short passes, through balls, shooting combinations, and goals. There are no through balls slicing in from the flanks, and no real opportunities to take on defenders with dynamic dribbling. Goals always stem from very similar, predictable positions.
3- Long-Range Shots: Following up on weak headers, long-range powerful shots are another major issue—a problem that has persisted since 2017. Long shots almost always end up comfortably caught in the goalkeeper's hands. Please update the shooting power bar so that applying maximum power genuinely triggers blistering, high-velocity strikes. While scoring from 25–30 meters out shouldn't be easy, players should be able to unleash unexpected thunderbolts that force goalkeepers into different animations—sometimes watching it fly past, sometimes diving spectacularly for world-class saves. Top-corner screamers and long-range finesse shots need to feel much more rewarding and impactful.
4- Goalkeeper AI on Crosses and Loose Balls: Goalkeeper AI during crosses and balls played out wide is weak. Sometimes, the goalkeeper awkwardly runs inside the goal line for balls rolling out for a goal kick. Their reactions to loose balls outside the six-yard box need massive improvements (and I am not talking just about shot-stopping). Goalkeeper behavior during dead-ball situations or corner kicks in empty space is simply poor.
5- New Cutscenes and Animations: We need fresh cutscenes and animations. For example, when the ball goes out for a goal kick, the keeper could gesture to the ball boy or teammates to hurry up and throw the ball—that would be a great touch. Injury cutscenes could be varied. During stoppages, players could walk over to the manager for a quick chat, or water breaks could be introduced. A VAR system should be added: in local co-op, both players could simultaneously press a specific button (like the substitution trigger) to request a VAR review, leading to a dedicated cutscene for the referee's final decision. Referees should feature varied animations when issuing cards. A "protest" button could be added, where protesting players risk being booked by the referee.
- In important matches, when a team falls behind, cutscenes showing players showing grit and determination, or hyping each other up after a crucial defensive tackle, should be added.
- Team goal music could be integrated.
- Pre-match walkout cutscenes and national anthems can be added.
- UI menus should change dynamically when a tournament trophy is won.
- Free-kick run-ups and shooting styles could be diversified per player.
- Sometimes on long-range free kicks, even when filling the power bar completely, the ball travels too slowly—this bug needs to be fixed.
- A "shirt removal" celebration animation after scoring could be introduced, making players weigh the risk of getting a yellow card.
- Managers should be able to protest decisions against the referee and risk getting booked themselves.
6- Match Flow and AI Behavior Variety: In terms of gameplay, the AI always offers a very similar playstyle. For each match, the AI's tactical approach should dynamically vary—sometimes shooting heavily, sometimes passing around safely without forcing shots, sometimes taking massive risks, or sometimes sitting deep. While these can theoretically be customized, their actual impact on the pitch is currently minimal.
7- Match State and AI Adaptability: AI understanding of the scoreline is severely lacking:
- When trailing behind, the opponent AI should take much greater risks, push forward aggressively, and leave gaps at the back—which currently rarely happens.
- Conversely, when leading, they should drop deeper to protect the lead.
- "Anadolu" (mid-to-lower tier) clubs playing away against big teams should genuinely make you feel that pressure, while big teams visiting smaller stadiums should be forced to deal with lethal counter-attacks from their opponents.
8- Referee Logic and Advantage Rule: The referee's advantage rule needs to become much more flexible and intelligent. In professional last-man fouls denying clear goal-scoring opportunities, the referee should immediately sprint over with a dedicated animation and brandish a red card. Right now, whether the referee gives a yellow or a red, their reaction looks identical, making it feel lifeless—almost as if the referee isn't even there.
9- Simulation and Animations: If a player dives (simulation mechanic), the referee should have an animation gesturing back at the player, indicating they simulated a dive.
10- Injury and Recovery Mechanics: In injury situations, injured players immediately signal for a substitution without even testing their condition or coming over to the sideline. They should be able to test their fitness on the touchline and ask the fourth official for permission to re-enter the game.
11- Fatigue Impact: Player running animations and strides should visibly change as they get heavily fatigued.
12- Shielding and Physical Battles: Shielding the ball currently relies on very limited mechanics, and physical duels feel too script-bound. If a forward has superior physical strength, they should dominate the duel; if the defender is stronger, they should win it naturally.
13- Momentum and Artificial Slowdown: One of the biggest frustrations is the momentum system. When playing against AI, if I am sprinting with a player who has 90 pace, and an opponent with 40 pace chases me down, the game artificially feels sluggish and heavy. It makes my player feel slower than the opponent, allowing their defender to easily catch up and take the ball. The game shouldn't feel slowed down just to handicap the user. The challenge from the AI should come from their football intelligence and gameplay quality, not by tampering with the game's speed.