Forum Discussion

antonic0318's avatar
1 year ago

Review of Legendary 5star Card

Dear EA,

I would like to raise a concern on a legendary 5* Card-  "Schmeichel "Speed"
Further to the newly released 5 star GK- Van Der Sar, the concerned card is observed to be much weaker. Reasons identified below:

  • Rating & skill mismatch - "PUNCH" rating is too low fundamentally consider the key "RED/176+" skill is a "PUNCH"
  • Non Outstanding "HIGH BALL" & " LOW BALL" saving addition- a barely "good' 
  • Failure to deal with striker with same attribute - chance of saving  shoot from same attribute striker are founded higher from other GK eg. Van der Sar, Alison

Taken into account the strength of the card in "low cost of stamina in punch" & "a consistent 110% in rating in regular rank match", the concerned card is still even weaker than a TOTY Allison. For a better and fair gaming experience for player who spent more on legend card, please consider my suggest below"

  • To raise the base rating of "Punch" ; retain the overall rating by balancing 
  • to consider enhancing "HIGH BALL" & " LOW BALL" saving addition to "Very good" partially.
  • Generally, attempt to keep legend 5* cards  up to a certain standard ; at least comparable to a TOTY, FCL, FTCC, Flash back etc. considering the cost play spent and their rarity.
  • To launch the revised card via "Revival "event as a formal notice to existing player / to attract new players

It is understood there has been thoughtful consideration / set-up / design on each cards from EA game developer. Thanks for the effort . Having said this, an interactive review would always help improve.

I declare i do own this card. However, regularly review on all Legendary card generally is beneficial to both existing players and EA  as it is strongly believed any qualified/up-to-standard card  always attract buyers to attain.

Your sincerely,
AY
Game ID: *

*[Removed by CM]

3 Replies

  • EA_LeonSK's avatar
    EA_LeonSK
    Icon for EA SPORTS FC™ Team rankEA SPORTS FC™ Team
    1 year ago

    Hi @antonic0318,

    Thank you so much for your feedback related to the Schmeichel item. I agree with you that reviews and feedback from passionate players are always useful for the Team.

    We can raise your advice to the Team but you can't guarantee the changes you're asking for. 

    Said that, I want to thank you again for the very detailed feedback with a good comparison with other goalkeepers present in the game.

  • Thanks for your response . Much appreciated.

    Please also let the team to consider:

    1. The cost for Non-legendary Card to boost the red skill to Max is absolutely incomparable to that for a legend card . It is observed nowadays Alison( without multiplication in rank match; with an estimation of max for special attributes ) can do a High ball  Saving reaching 45000+ . Meanwhile, schmeichel can only do a 38000+ considering all factor .  These factual results worth consideration.

    2. Rationale of GK's stat is apparently different from FW, MF ,DF in the sense GK actually has no choice in combat. For instance, It is not like a FW can do a dribble over opponent’s interception to gain 130% up. A GK with a balanced stat would be absolutely weaker than one with an extreme case. The truth is Schmeichel is even at a poor condition for his mismatch “punch” stat as discussed “


    3. I understand it is a bit unfair to compare “speed” and “strength “ Goalkeeper . To certain extent, Van der sar could be designed for Drogba, Van Basten;  schmeichel is for 5star speed"  Haaland, Mabbappe, Messi. Maybe the way to measure/ Gauge a GK is the chance/proximity to save all secondary shoots / non red skill from  attribute striker.

    Taken into account of a +40000 normal shot , the Turth is a Max Alison now can almost save most shots from a. 4star "Techniques" striker (including legend card) or even half-trained 5star MF "Techniques " legend eg del perio , Zidane, Gerrard . If this is the benchmark, please consider parity.

    Again, thanks for the review and EA effort for the development. sorry for the long  essay . 

    regards

    AY

  • Dear EA , 

    The new fix has been causing even big problem as the advantages of "speed" card over "strength" has been reduced greatly.

    That means some "strength" attckers can even scored over Schmeichel from high ball and can potentially be  invincible scorers.

    Again , please kinkdy review the ball "punching" ability and "high ball "of the only LEGENDARY "speed"GK  (please measure  how strong is  van de sar strong and do level Schmeichel  ability with legend card and also with  just a TOTY GK alision at least) 

    Regards

Featured Places

Node avatar for EA SPORTS FC™ TACTICAL

EA SPORTS FC™ TACTICAL

Discuss the latest news and talk with us about your experiences in FC TACTICAL.Latest Activity: 1 hour ago
119 Posts