The same here. I play as a CB. Get As nearly every game. I have the #1 scoring defense, 2 of the top 3 sacks leaders and im tied for 1st with interceptions and my QB influence is 0 because giving up a 1st down is impacting me more than getting off the field on 3rd down. If the opposing team has 7 1st downs and give up 2 TD, which is a great defensive game, that's-410 points to my QB influence. But if I have a pass break-up, 2 tackle and 10 3rd stops and a bunch of great covers, it's only +235. And because my QB is at a zero (0), he is garbage. So im mostly playing on short fields because of turnovers or 3 and outs. Then the animation saying im doing a bad job when I just had an A+ game.
We should get influence on all sacks and turnovers. Especially if we get penalized when someone else gives up a td. A 3rd down stop getting off the field is worth 3 times a 1st down given up to start a drive. And the QB shouldn't be so dramatically impacted on little things like a first down. In real life (which madden is supposed to be trying to get to) the QB loves to get the valley back and go to work on Offense. This is one of the worse parts about superstar. It should be a simple and fast fix.