The replay system needs completely rebuilt

Situations that should trigger replays.

Penalties. 

3rd or 4th down pass breakups.

3rd or 4th down incomplete passes.

3rd or 4th down QB pressure hurries.

3rd or 4th down defensive stops.

3rd or 4th down offensive conversions. 

Also more replay diversity. The game shows the same 2-3 replays. Add more replay memory so the game can show more replays. 

Post game highlight montage that we can click and view again if we want.

More highlights at halftime.

More highlights in the post game replay montage. 

End of game per player replay montage. For example post game I should be able to choose a WR and see replays of that player like in NBA 2k.

More zoomed out replay views 

Mid game replay highlights from another game.