Insanity ll not being awarded

So it did not pop for insanity 2 or 3 on xbox for me, however, i i decided to try something that was similar to workaround for paramour issue. After beating me 2 on insanity i went back to save file me1 and did final battle again. It popped insanity 2. Tried one more time just to see, didnt pop the 3 rd one. Went and beat   me3 on insanity. No pop. Roaded game/ restart console. Did final boss  me1 insanity.  Third one popped. Its a pain doing it this way but final boss on me1 isnt soo bad so no big deal.