I don't think anyone opinion should be irrelevant. I am also an offline player and have been through many years where the focus was not a hockey experience whatsoever - with gameplay that was on the level of an "expensive game of pond hockey".
This gameplay is closer to how it was prior and is easily amore simulated experience - with less speed, stamina and a need for more skill based hockey plays - don't get me wrong its not not perfect by any means and is still full of random glitches, but it is better then prior years. There is actual needs to dump the puck for a line change, make quick passes to get into a zone (instead of just speed boosting past the dman), risk and reward to going for a check or keeping a line out for too long. Goalies are still so and so but I feel they are slightly improved over last year (not by much - there is still some weird animations).
I have played 87 games in my franchise and have to say that for me playing on a hard difficulty that its the most fun I have had since NHL 21.
I know that the online experience isn't the same so I can see and understand players complaints there, especially with the removal of the matchmaking thing that was used. I know that feels cause it was the same for me when they removed full presentation.