Forum Discussion
You’re misrepresenting the argument entirely.
I never said “Madden sold badly, so NHL should too.”
What I said — and I quote myself — was:
“Madden’s PC run hasn’t delivered major results. NHL could easily match or surpass it if given the opportunity. But that opportunity is constantly denied — based on outdated assumptions, not facts.”
That’s not flawed logic. That’s calling out the inconsistency in how EA applies standards.
Madden gets continued support despite weak performance. NHL doesn’t get a single test.
So if we’re basing decisions on performance — then why is Madden still here?
If you’re going to call out logic, at least read what was actually said.
Also — “you used GPT” isn’t a valid argument. I could write my post in Notepad, Google Docs, or with a stick in the sand — the numbers and logic stay the same.
Try harder.
Denchiks37 wrote:Madden’s PC run hasn’t delivered major results. NHL could easily match or surpass it if given the opportunity
based on what logic.