Can't take faceoffs with stick to left side

As this post from july   https://answers.ea.com/t5/Technical-Issues/Can-t-take-faceoffs-with-stick-to-left-side/m-p/9332619/highlight/false#M3579

explains I cant take faceoffs to with left side of my controller. There was no answer on how to fix this it starting do it in nhl 20 and no it it does it 21 with all controllers I go into xbox accessories app check my stick positioning and I'm under the 9 0'clock horizon 100 times out of 100 YET every time in-game it says I'm early. I tried switching to playing downwards and no issue then switch back to going up and it happens again. What is the solution? This is driving my insane