Ea's swing mechanic
Has anyone other than myself wished that EA had somewhere documented exactly how their swing mechanic works? Like what exactly constitutes a perfect swing tempo. And how that timing correlates with ...
Forum Discussion
@7AnimalMother wrote:I disagree. I do not find 2k consistent or repeatable at all. It's the main reason I don't play that game much anymore. I have both the PC and XBox X version of the game and I even made a macro on pc to see if I could get timing to be consistent. Even with my PC sending the swing inputs at EXACLTY the same cadence EVERY time, the 2k swing was jacked.
I guess we will just have to agree to disagree. I have just gone back to playing 2K23 after a 5 month hiatus. And though my timing is not what it was I am still consistently making good shots.
Which I forgot... you can actually tell by the sound of the ball coming off the club. You hear the difference between a well struck ball vs one that has been mistimed.
I would expect creating a macro should replicate the same shot. But did your marco take into consideration which club you are using? I'm wondering if each club has a slightly longer swing arc which might be affecting the timing. Something you wouldn't notice while playing because you are watching the animation of your character.
I have always played on PS which has better polling, which from what I understand gives us a slight advantage.
Hmm good thought on the macros for different clubs. I think I just made it based on the driver, though I feel like I still hit duck hooks and shanks with that club using the macro..
@ELF014 wrote:
@7AnimalMother wrote:I disagree. I do not find 2k consistent or repeatable at all. It's the main reason I don't play that game much anymore. I have both the PC and XBox X version of the game and I even made a macro on pc to see if I could get timing to be consistent. Even with my PC sending the swing inputs at EXACLTY the same cadence EVERY time, the 2k swing was jacked.
I guess we will just have to agree to disagree. I have just gone back to playing 2K23 after a 5 month hiatus. And though my timing is not what it was I am still consistently making good shots.
Which I forgot... you can actually tell by the sound of the ball coming off the club. You hear the difference between a well struck ball vs one that has been mistimed.
I would expect creating a macro should replicate the same shot. But did your marco take into consideration which club you are using? I'm wondering if each club has a slightly longer swing arc which might be affecting the timing. Something you wouldn't notice while playing because you are watching the animation of your character.
I have always played on PS which has better polling, which from what I understand gives us a slight advantage.
I do agree the sound of the ball coming off did change, that was nice.
