I started playing golf games competitively with Links 2001. The sad part is after all this time I still feel like the Links games were the most complete golf games. In Links everyone had the same stats so it was all about skill. After Links kinda went under i switched to Shot Online which was a whole different experience. SO is a golf MMORPG with unrealistic but challenging game play. Club distance is insane, but you need to use spin on the ball to achieve those. Yes you can hit the ball 700 yrds, but controlling it is another story. Also there was a lot to that game in regards to FW lies and what not. They would severely impact your shot. The main issue w/ shot online is that stat gap and cash shop. People would spend thousands and even 10s of thousands on clubs, stat items, clothes, exp items, etc etc....When I first started playing this was not much of an issue, but as the game grew the cash shop just kept getting worse and worse till I could not keep up. Pretty soon the pure distance between guys could not be made up by just skill alone. They did create tournaments where everyone had the same stats or same stat pool at least which was nice, but it was kinda too late at that point. I would love to see an AAA company make a shot online type game w/o all the cash shop items. Cosmetics could make a killing if the rest of the game was good.
With all that being said I think EA made a good game, but woefully lacking in features. I think what they have is very solid, but its pretty criminal the lack of game modes they came out with. No turn based match play is just head scratching. I could understand if they were a new company jumping into the market, but they had good success w/ the TW games so you would think they should have been able to build on those w/o stripping most of the game play modes. The game was delayed for like a year then again so I am not sure what they were focusing on. I will continue to play as I like the game they just need to add more competitive features. I wish they would have teams and some sort of format for those along w/ ranked match play games.