@Iron_Guard8 This was the first character I mastered in gw2.
I think Torchwood does the pure tank role better than either version of citron tbh. High health, leaf shield comes with downsides, slow, will slaughter at close range but fall off hard at longe range, and is usually focused fire to buy time for his team. Iron citron also leans towards this more.
Ballers are annoying but they're usually just free vanquishes rather than a threat.
The beam was annoying before the fix but now I'd say it's pretty acceptable now. I prefer the non laser citron variants like iron and toxic. Frozen is annoying to go up against because hes a class with a stun and ice powers, he was always gonna be annoying. Electro needs a buff but I dont think he's as terrible as everyone says.
Mood shield is a good alternative to peel shield and it represents its health better but your far better off waiting until your losing a fight to use it.
I always hated how impeach did a bit of damage to non z mechs in gw2 and I'm glad bfn removed that, but now its far to effective when used with 75 Insta dash of death.
Why did popcap make a 75 Insta dash for citron? Did they expect every imp to be overhealed when fighting a citron? Its a busted ability and I prefer being able to at least see citron get into ball form in gw2 first.
Naval laser was a pain to fight at the start of bfn. It could shred space stations and basically brought back the beam problem on steroids. Even at the end of bfn good aim with it is still deadly.
The empeach removing z mech fuel is too powerful of a counter since 2 citrons can shutdown any z mech offensive.
Now the shield.
It's too good. They missed the point of Reinhardt completely being defenseless at range and being in a game where its 6v6 close quarters so Reinhardt's shield can be focused fired. This isn't possible in bfn where its 12v12/8v8 with people playing multiple of the same characters except battle arena but arena sucks and the shield can still soak up too much damage before the zombies get wiped. Overwatch also had the ultimates designed to team wipe even the toughest of characters and shields, bfn doesn't have this. Citron being able to REGENERATE HEALTH while his shield up is nothing short of bs and another thing they failed to learn from Reinhardt. Combine this with the empeach, 75 damage spin dash, and citrons high close range damage and you have the most annoying character to 1v1 in the game from the plant team.
Even without his shield he can easily escape with his high health and empeach than just wait for the shield to quickly recharge.
I don't hate his new model but like you said it looks plastic and the sunglasses from gw2 looked a lot better for his cool guy aesthetic and his body not being connected by the little stalk like it was in gw2 leads to an awkward walk cycle of bouncing up and down in bfn.
I feel like the gw2 version but with a few qol changes would be the best version of the character.