Mandalorian discussion[SPOILERS]
This will be a discussion thread for The Mandalorian. Just for thoughts and predictions on the show, and stuff. If you want to talk about how cute Baby Yoda is, go ahead, if you want to talk about ho...
Forum Discussion
@HCarbonic Yeah, when I saw how Cobb got the armour in the TV show, I quietly said, “That’s not how it happened.”
@SuperSpyUU Its kind of a strech but it is sort of possible to make them match by assuming both accounts don't show the full thing,
for instance aftermath doesn't say how Vanth got into the sand crawler it just says Adwin heard someone clear his throat from behind him so it can be assumed he was already there.
I guess the whole conversation with Adwin Charu takes place after he sees the armor and before they give it to him. Im gonna say the jawas didn't give it to him right away but he had claim on it and/or they were debating on wheter or not to give it to him because it was so valubable.
It also depends on how much of what he told charu was the truth.
The main discrepancies i see are just the fact that it says it was in a box in aftermath and in the show its on the wall.
and the fact that he claims tuskens cant be reasoned with even though he made a deal with them to liberate freetown, Also it says he gave them a pearl from a krayt dragon which would imply they had killed one before
maybe the smaller canyon variety.
sorry for the lack of grammer im kinda in a hurry.
for instance aftermath doesn't say how Vanth got into the sand crawler it just says Adwin heard someone clear his throat from behind him so it can be assumed he was already there.
I guess the whole conversation with Adwin Charu takes place after he sees the armor and before they give it to him. Im gonna say the jawas didn't give it to him right away but he had claim on it and/or they were debating on wheter or not to give it to him because it was so valubable.
It also depends on how much of what he told charu was the truth.
The main discrepancies i see are just the fact that it says it was in a box in aftermath and in the show its on the wall.
and the fact that he claims tuskens cant be reasoned with even though he made a deal with them to liberate freetown, Also it says he gave them a pearl from a krayt dragon which would imply they had killed one before
maybe the smaller canyon variety.
sorry for the lack of grammer im kinda in a hurry.
- @SwellingFoil266 That would make sense. So maybe Cobb was in there for a much longer time than we thought. I'll have to reread the interlude (it's around page 336 if anyone's interested)
It is kind of annoying that they couldn't replicate it. I mean they pretty much already had the script written for them. I guess it was just so people that hadn't read Aftermath would have a better time understanding. If you ask me though if they would have kept it how it was it would have just made people want to start reading books and comics and that wouldn't have been a bad thing.
Its not near as bad as the discrepancies between the clone wars and the ahsoka novel though.Chapter 2 releases tomorrow! Can I get a GONK in the chat?
